The thing is, fitness is absolutely key in the Premier League. It is the fastest, most physically demanding League in the entire world.
When players get a serious injury there is 1: the time it takes for the injury to heal, 2: the time it takes them to mentally overcome it (i.e.trust their body again) and then 3: the time it takes them to regain full peak performance physical fitness.
We have suffered with probably more serious injuries in the last 5 years than any other club. Gomes was one of the worst. Our problem is that when the injury heals, we believe they are ready again. They are not. To overcome the other 2 factors can be quick or slow depending on the player himself. Even those players who haven't had a serious injury, but lots of little niggles like Delph and Mina clearly struggle to trust their own body in the same way, which impacts their ability to regain full peak performance physical fitness.
But let's be clear, Gomes, Digne, Delph, Coleman, Gbamin are all top footballers from an ability point of view. They can all play the game. They wouldn't be in the Premier League otherwise. So let's not keep questioning their ability as we have all seen it at some stage (Gbamin pending). Being not in peak condition physically and mentally is the most likely cause of inconsistency.
So can they deal with the psychological injury scars that prevent them getting to absolute peak physical condition again? That is the question....
Over to the sports psychologists and the physical fitness coaches.
(Oh and we also have a duty as fans to help these players and encourage them as much possible. Look at our impact Monday night... )