Agreed, there is a place for it, rolling the ball around the back is great when we are leading, its great when we are getting back into position.
But, it's when it's the only play we have and the midfield work it back because 'they only know that'. Or the forwards work it back to the midfield and they in turn pass it on to the defence because 'they only know that'. The comfort blanket of passing responsibility onto the defence is utterly nuts. It has its place in a jam, but every play? Expecting Pirlo distribution from die hard defenders (specifically CB) is giving the scalpel to the three year old. Denying them the get out of jail free card to hoof it forward is just putting pressure on Howard, who has come under even greater pressure because the buck is stopping with him more and more. Its crazy.
Heres a question. How can the defence be expected to move the ball around better than the midfield? If they could they'd be shuffled forward to do the distribution damage instead of the charlatans that were there. They cant. Defenders defend. Its why Hibbert has won plaudits yet again this season for doing his primary job.
So far as one flank to another, that too has its place, but not in the 5 minutes it takes us to manage, everyone needs a few touches, like its some business deal you need your signiture on enough times to make sure you get credit for the deal and therefore paid when it goes through. It's sad, it's slow and it's suicide again.
I'm starting to think the vigour and speed the side showed last year was because they had been freed from the Moyes vice of defence first, second and third. The thing is, that was still imprinted on them and they fell back into it with ease, the longer it has gone the more sloppy we have looked. 'Titting about in defence' has made that sloppiness more evident than natural disinclination would have.
The fear and the mistakes in our side now are exactly the same as the ones in his Wigan side. Time to change the philosophy, because it aint working.