Benitez has got a tune out of a poor squad so far, but tonight shows up two things: first, the lack of real depth in this squad and, second, his own pig-headedness.
First, the squad. We lost four players (Coleman, Pickford, Richarlison, and DCL) and have capitulated to another ordinary side. That'd be concerning if it was not predictable. The start to the season was not a new dawn - just the latest false one for those who insist on believing when the evidence once more points to this run being us in one of our better, ephemeral moments.
As for Benitez, he is entitled to live and die by his decisions. That's why he is the manager. However, if you cannot fill your bench in the absence of four first-teamers, surely you place James Rodriguez on it if only to complete the numbers. Is he also injured or unavailable? Or is this simply a choice of the manager. As mentioned, he is entitled to make his choice, but he will be judged for it if the results are not good - and tonight the result is most definitely not good. Rodriguez is a circus - I have no doubt about that - but the manager should still attempt to get the best out of his resources, even if that means filling his bench. Tonight, his choice/spite has left him exposed to criticism. Perhaps he's comfortable with that, but this is a J. Rod that some will now use to beat him with.