A terrible beauty is born! lol
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
- Status
Disagree, these lads too.
Euro 2020 - Billy Gilmour praised by Jose Mourinho, Steve Clarke after Scotland drew with England - TNT Sports
Steve Clarke and Jose Mourinho praised the performance of Billy Gilmour as Scotland fought hard to earn a 0-0 draw with England at Wembley on Friday night.
www.eurosport.co.uk
Simon Buttle
Player Valuation: £50m
I'm not sure if you have noticed or not but it's nearly 2023 not 2020, since then Gilmour has failed to make the grade at Chelsea, failed to pull up any trees at Norwich and then failed again to hold down a place at Brighton. He also didn't make the last International squad. There is some obvious ability there with the lad but I just don't think he is suited towards this league/game hence why he has been linked with moves abroad.Disagree, these lads too.
Euro 2020 - Billy Gilmour praised by Jose Mourinho, Steve Clarke after Scotland drew with England - TNT Sports
Steve Clarke and Jose Mourinho praised the performance of Billy Gilmour as Scotland fought hard to earn a 0-0 draw with England at Wembley on Friday night.
The fact that he can’t get into the current Scottish squad, tells you all you need to know, about his current level.
He’ll either be playing in Turkey or league one next year.
By that logic has James Garner has failed to make grade and on the scrap heap, rejected by Utd, wasn’t signed by the team he was promoted and they made a few and spent much and can’t break into the Everton team. Garners older than Gilmour, yet we see him as one for the future. Gilmour has CL experience and a Medal and played at World Level.
If you apply much of the logic in this thread on Gilmour to Garner, well……
Last edited:
I don’t remember him being dropped from the Scotland squad?
There was a squad he wasn’t in because on injury this year….
Simon Buttle
Player Valuation: £50m
Garner can't break into anything because he is out for 3 months with a back injury. None of our new midfielders have impressed me tbh as the setup is so wrong it's not getting the best out of them. If he is so great then surely one of the big teams will come in for him?
JLW
Player Valuation: £60m
Yes mate but after we’ve signed them, how many threads have we had of players were linked with but never signed.
Come on mate, Garners injury came in the close season, that’s not a valid point. My point is Gilmour is younger, achieved more so far, yet both are the same age, Gilmour younger, yet we see Garner as one with potential for the future and Gilmour career is over, yet both are inhabiting the same space in their development at their respective clubs. I’m not slating either, I’m challenging the prevailing logic and reframing amongst players with clear parrells in their profiles showing the obvious contradiction.
He’s young mate, it’s my understanding Chelsea didn’t want to sell, but the lad himself said he wanted to move to try and get more game time. It’s up to him now, he has the technical ability but has to develop and progress, he’s still very young, i wouldnt rule out a move up the ladder in the future, but it’s up to the lad. It’s easy to comment on the present, it’s harder and braver to try and predict the future, that’s not a reason why we shouldn’t try and do it. It’s a bit of fun at the end of the day and if nothing else lads get all worked up and you trigger them to start threads like this. It’s all a bit of fun,
I like it, if you see something in a player have the guts to say it, it’s half the fun of this place and sure laugh a long if you drop a clanger. I like Billy though, he has a rare composure and technical ability.
Last edited:
Simon Buttle
Player Valuation: £50m
It's as valid as you quoting stuff about his form from 3 years ago ffs. Nobody has said Gilmours career is over, they just don't rate him and you seem to have a massive issue with this. Hopefully his career gets back on track, I'm saying nothing more on the subject as it's boring the hell out of me and I want to go smoke a joint, have a fun evening mate
It's as valid as you quoting stuff about his form from 3 years ago ffs. Nobody has said Gilmours career is over, they just don't rate him and you seem to have a massive issue with this. Hopefully his career gets back on track, I'm saying nothing more on the subject as it's boring the hell out of me and I want to go smoke a joint, have a fun evening mate
The quote I posted from 2020 was in response to a post of a video clip posted to me, from a game in 2020 and his perfromence in that game so the context is relevant, you misinterpreted it.
0 issue with lads posting opinion and not rating him, it’s a debating forum ffs…this is the point contrasting views - I’m actually being civil responding to points you made quoting me, so not sure how I have a serious issue with lads not rating him, you started the interaction, I’m not going to be a sheep and agree when I don’t, not rating him is defo the prevailing passive view, but that’s the fun. lol
Enjoy mate!
Makes davies look like zidane no thanks
- Status