I'm annoyed by comparisons to Moyes and pining for his return. He was great for us at the time, but he moved on, never seems to talk about us, and it never works to bring someone like that back.
There were a lot of good things about Moyes at Everton, but IMO
- He could never get strikers to work well here, despite being able to spend on some big ones - Johnson, Beattie, people like that were here and were decent at the time, but nobody scored a lot until Yakubu.
- Tactically we were inflexible
- We were fortunate to have excellent players at the right age, Baines, Cahill, Arteta, Coleman, Jags, Distin, Howard - an excellent core
- His recruitment at the time was really good, and they recruited leaders, which we have yet to do - and that helped a lot.
- Even though we had 'big characters' , he could still not create an atmosphere and mentality to beat bigger teams, even sometimes!
- ...and that's true even though there were really only 6 top teams, and were always easily 7th, and nobody really threatened the top 7 much - in fact, Man City and Spurs were not even as good at that time and the reds were inconsistent
So overall it worked because of the timing as well, and he just wouldn't work because of what is required now- this type of rebuild is different and Ancelotti will come good for us!