It’s a bit mad. Like you say, I remember him having some great games early season, especially that Liverpool game. He was getting a lot of praise and I think he was MOTM in a few matches. He was basically first choice and defensively we looked better then than now.
He is certainly not as bad as is being made out and I’ve no idea why he’s being left out for Holgate and Godfrey. He might be rusty/not fit but then isn’t it Dyche’s job to get players back up to the mark and integrate them back?
He might be the only player who is remembered more negatively for being out, usually it’s the opposite.