Eva Carneiro leaves Chelsea

[Mikey_Fitzgerald]

She would additionally have medical board/licensing regulations to be followed not to mention ethical.

Exactly

As I've already said, he'll settle out of court

 

[marty mcfly]

Ok, getting it back on topic and away from the sexism angle - what exactly do you think the medical staff did that was wrong a) on the day b) in the follow up?

I don't think they did anything wrong on the day but I do think she shouldn't have thanked people for their support afterwards. She should have known how Mourinho would have reacted to that. I still don't think that's a reason for her to be demoted or moved off "active duty" at least not permanently which is why I think there's more going on behind the scenes regarding this issue.

I think Mourinho made a mistake but in the pressure cooker environment that can happen.

The biggest mistake made was by the media turning this into a huge story.

 

[marty mcfly]

Yeah...she sure looks a right meek little thing that everyone should be concerned with defending.

I agree with that. I'm not saying she is a meek little thing at all. I'm saying the media is treating her like one.

If anything the dude is the meek one taking the abuse.

 

[ilikecheese]

She's 100% in the wrong.

I don't think they did anything wrong on the day but I do think she shouldn't have thanked people for their support afterwards. She should have known how Mourinho would have reacted to that. I still don't think that's a reason for her to be demoted or moved off "active duty" at least not permanently which is why I think there's more going on behind the scenes regarding this issue.

I think Mourinho made a mistake but in the pressure cooker environment that can happen.

The biggest mistake made was by the media turning this into a huge story.

Which is it?

 

[marty mcfly]

Which is it?

She's 100% in the wrong when it comes to an unfair dismissal case and that her treatment by Mourinho had anything to do with sexism.

 

[LinekersLegs]

I don't think they did anything wrong on the day but I do think she shouldn't have thanked people for their support afterwards. She should have known how Mourinho would have reacted to that. I still don't think that's a reason for her to be demoted or moved off "active duty" at least not permanently which is why I think there's more going on behind the scenes regarding this issue.

I think Mourinho made a mistake but in the pressure cooker environment that can happen.

The biggest mistake made was by the media turning this into a huge story.

Surprised you have just spent the past few pages arguing if that is your take on the subject.

Personally am glad that this has the profile that it has, it has forced FIFA and the Fa to be far more public in their support for doctors and to state unequivocally that players health is the primary importance.

 

[ilikecheese]

She's 100% in the wrong when it comes to an unfair dismissal case and that her treatment by Mourinho had anything to do with sexism.

How could she be in the wrong for the unfair dismissal case when she did nothing wrong on the day?

 

[Titus Bramble]

She's 100% in the wrong. She's not a normal doctor because she's part of the team and Mourinho was right that she made a mistake in the context of the game and who are we to argue that it wasn't a mistake that she made.

He then treated her exactly the same as the male colleague and afterwards she went on social media and undermined his position.

There's definitely sexism at play here but it's the fact that deep down everyone feels sorry for Eva Carneiro, the pretty young female doctor getting a verbal assault from Jose Mourinho, the grumpy old man.

Frankly this whole case will set back equality decades because it shows in a male competitive environment hiring women is a risk.

I still hope he loses.

She's 100% in the wrong when it comes to an unfair dismissal case and that her treatment by Mourinho had anything to do with sexism.

So she's been wrong from start to finish?

A bit like you funnily enough.

 

[tommye]

Why on earth are you all even debating this with him? He's obviously a knobhead and you are all as bad as him for arguing. Was his cockwombling in the transfer threads not enough for you?


Jesus weeps at your collective bellwhiffery.

 

[marty mcfly]

Surprised you have just spent the past few pages arguing if that is your take on the subject.

Personally am glad that this has the profile that it has, it has forced FIFA and the Fa to be far more public in their support for doctors and to state unequivocally that players health is the primary importance.

There is that but it's a shame it will probably ruin her career.

 

[marty mcfly]

How could she be in the wrong for the unfair dismissal case when she did nothing wrong on the day?

Because she did wrong afterwards and unfair dismissal is very hard to prove. That said Chelsea will probably settle if it goes that far.

 

[LinekersLegs]

There is that but it's a shame it will probably ruin her career.

Mourinho being an idiot will ruin her career?

And what about Fearn's career that is currently on hold when he didn't even make a mild facebook post?

 

[Donald Twain]

Why on earth are you all even debating this with him? He's obviously a knobhead and you are all as bad as him for arguing. Was his cockwombling in the transfer threads not enough for you?


Jesus weeps at your collective bellwhiffery.

lol Tommye knocking heads together. These are great days lads.

 

[Donald Twain]

and lasses.

 

[marty mcfly]

Mourinho being an idiot will ruin her career?

And what about Fearn's career that is currently on hold when he didn't even make a mild facebook post?

Fearn didn't do anything wrong. He didn't argue back and has kept a low profile since. Mourinho will allow him back on to the bench because he's stayed loyal and hasn't questioned his authority.

Surely you must realize that's how it works.

Last season Distin probably had a point with Martinez but it didn't stop Martinez from making him train with the U21s and only reluctantly allowing him to play a few mins in his last game. Football managers don't tolerate insubordination. It doesn't matter if they are right or wrong. It's their way or the highway.