Everton Premier League era player nominees

[Nymzee]

Anyone who puts James Rodriguez is overrated is absolutely mental and/or still smashed from last night.

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

Wayne Rooney is comfortably the best, though you could argue he didn’t stay long enough to have the required influence.

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

Hardly played?

He played in 2/3rds of our games mate, he was absolutely unreal. Never seen a player for everton as good as he was. Shame that fat horrible pig got rid.

Rooney was much better.

 

[blulouie]

The Best James Rodriguez
could have been Rooney ( plus most potential ) but sold too soon brought back too late.

Worst Cuco Martina
Although lots run him close.

Most overated Phil Neville
Atrocious footballer , notorious finger pointer.

Best passer , best skills & one season wonder James Rodriguez.

Best Shot & wasted potential Bily.

Funniest Yakubu.

 

[Exeter_Gently]

The most underrated player - Leon Osman
The most overrated player - Duncan Ferguson
The Best - Neville Southall
The Worst - Richard Wright

Richard Wright was proper poo wasn't he.

 

[Cels]

Richard Wright was proper poo wasn't he.

I hate slagging our players off, but I really thought he was a very poor keeper

​

 

[Goodisongang]

Rooney was much better.

Yer maybe, completely different types though, Rooney was just raw and untreal, but the technique from Rodriguez in that season was just something I've never seen from an everton player.

 

[Tim's tourettes]

Worst = Brett angel or Alex nyarko

 

[Cels]

Bump!

 

[blue61]

What category are we on?

 

[Cels]

What category are we on?

I think it's still "worst player"

 

[blue61]

I think it's still "worst player"

Too many to choose from.

 

[Arteta2391]

we are looking for worst PL era Everton player next

 

[StateSideToffee]

Without question the worst ever PL Era Everton player is one of the following:

Ashley Williams, Aidan McGeady, Michael Keane, or Ashley Young.

I would easily accept an arguement for any of them but for me, it's Ashley Williams.

 

[.....!]

Worst and most recent.... Maupay. Little scruff.