Zatara
Player Valuation: £100m
I've been thinking of this conundrum (and this example) a fair bit.
You will have to pay for a fair amount of "english tax" (and probably doubly so given you are buying and selling from England) but the benefits are that you have seen the player deliver in England's top division. There should be a price to that. Now whether we feel that price should be below, above or at about the level it's at is interesting, but we should accept that such a premium exists and for where we are, it's worth considering.
The key mistake we probably made in the past, was paying that additional fee on declining assets. To me it is different buying players under 25 and doing it. You are just much more likely to put a tick in the box.
If we had a big sale, I'd be very open to bringing in a Neto, Bissouma in midfield etc as while you can probably find players with a similar ceiling for less, I'm not sure they will have anything approaching the same floor.
Heres 3 things i am wondering:
1: Big name players not in a top 4 side
Under the assumption that we put down an acceptable offer for the player and offered a high wage...
If Rice doesnt go to United, who will sign him for £60mil+ ? Where does Soucek go? Could Moyes want one of our players in a swap deal...i dont know.
Will Neto and Neves get a move to a top 4 side?
These players would all cost a heavy premium but we 'may' have somewhat of a chance of signing them.
2: Young potential superstars overseas
Inter are desperate for money, could we get Lautaro? Bastoni? Hakimi?
Camavinga, Gravenberch, Kounde, Aouar, Wirtz, Tapsoba, Kamara, Bellingham, Bailey, Locatelli, Emerson etc etc
If we offer the money then would these types of players join the club to play for Ancelotti and know they can get regular game time?
Weve seen Bellingham supposedly turn United down as he wanted regular games which he got in Dortmund. Would players prefer to join us to make their mark on the premier league?
3: Players from less successful premier league teams
Bissouma and Lamptey at Brighton of course and (once they are promoted) Aarons and Buendia at Norwich...
These types of signings are less risky than overseas but due to the tv deal carry the premium -- the same goes for even championship players these days.
Are they big fish in a small pond and can they be a bigger fish in a larger pond?
Beyond these 3 options we of course have the discounted / out of contract older star players like Koulibaly and Ramos for example...those whose clubs are from 'weaker' leagues and perhaps the option of loans to buy as West Ham managed to do with Soucek.
The three main options would be the route i would primarily favour...where we are now i think we need to be building a team to carry us for the next 5-10 years of players whose values will increase and that we could sell at a huge premium to recycle players as Leicester, Dortmund and Atletico etc have done. But who can make an impact for us today.
If you pick out one player from each of those 3 options then you could expect our team to look far stronger next season.
We will need to spend serious money to break into that top 4 and stay there.