Yes, I've seen every match he's played for Everton. And Besic was not good for us last season. McCarthy wasnt either, still we played better with him on than Besic.
Okay mate. Besic made 19 appearances last year as he was injured for two lengthy spells.
Barnsley away he was poor in the first half but that was his first action in three months as he picked up an injury in pre-season so missed the entirety of it. He came good in the second half in that game.
Next game vs Spurs he came on as a sub and did fine, then against Chelsea he started and went off injured after 5 minutes.
I don't see how those three can be classed as 'bad'...
Fast forward to boxing day, which is the next time he played - a 10 minute sub appearance at St James' Park. He didn't play against Stoke but did come on after 60 mins at home vs Spurs. Completely swung the game in our favour and almost scored with what would have been a wonder goal.
Started the next game vs City in the Lg Cup and was absolutely fantastic, before running the show in the FA Cup (granted, vs a poor side). He was brilliant at the Etihad and once again in the next game at Stamford Bridge. The week after he hit the post and then went off injured after 5 minutes vs Swansea.
Came on for a bit vs W.Ham, but was awful in one of the worst team performances of the season vs Arsenal, and his season tailed off towards the end.
He wasn't bad at all. He was our best player for that spell he was fit in January by a country mile as well.
I agree, this needs to be the year he proves his quality, but I'm sure he can do it as long as he stays injury free. A full pre-season (compared to no pre-season last year) should help.