Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Fake News By Everton FC.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Id like the club to acknowledge or clarify it given the scope of reporting.

Im just playing devils advocate though, say it happened and DBB as CEO said, she didn’t want to report to try and convey unity and protect the reputation of the club - she has that right as a citizen, the club can’t force her. Not saying that happened, but not impossible either.

I agree though - the club is damned if they do or don’t here, but I think clarity is needed.
Mate as others have pointed out that’s just not how it works , otherwise the experience of opposing fans and how it’s policed would be very different wouldn’t it ?
 
Why would she not report it?.
Before yesterday she could have said , I don't want to inflame the situation, or I don't want to drag the clubs name through the mud.
That went out the window after yesterday's announcement.
I don't know what in reality happened, but i know if people were questioning me I would reply, otherwise it leaves an open door to people to say your basically a liar?
She owns nothing to someone treating her that way why not clear the air.
Obviously we’re both speculating mate, i don’t know if it’s true or not, seems reports are from a sourc3 in the club and national media so it’s a sketchy enough source.

To play devils advocate though, I’d suggest as CEO, she be keen to order ve the image of the club and fan base, having a CEO in headlock is bad publicity for the business, PR and her professionally, not to mention as a woman in sport. Secondly if it was pursued by the CPS she would have to give witness evidence, so she’d be in the dock giving evidence about a fan - I’d suggest that would be divisive and sadly there are many still in the city that would call her a grass. As it was against Brighton, things hadn’t got toxic by then, but since palpable tension has built, Moshiri during the week kicked it off, but at the time she may have thought by taking it further could have kicked off the toxicity we saw yesterday. Often victims of violence blame themselves or are paralysed by fear to anxiety if future reprocussions.

I don’t know if it’s true or not, but I do know a little but about trauma and PTSD reactions and victim psychology, If it did happen I’d hypothesise all or part of that could have been part of her decision making process.

Again not saying it did happen because it’s a sketchy source, just playing devils advocate really and hope it’s false.
 
Mate as others have pointed out that’s just not how it works , otherwise the experience of opposing fans and how it’s policed would be very different wouldn’t it ?

I did a bit in U.K. law and criminal justice back in the early 00s when I lived there, admittedly more in Scotland (which is different from England), while I do a bit in the area in Ireland sadly still - over here I think the threory is similar but in practice it’s very unlikely for a case to proceed if an allegation isn’t made or a victim is hostile (doesn’t assist the investigation). Happy to admit Law in England is something I wouldn’t be able to apply ver batem or may have changed since I worked there, so happy to defer to lads who may be more up to date - I don’t live in the U.K. these days, so likely out of the loop.

Are we sure a complaint hasn’t been made by DBB, she also has a right to confidentiality and through experience investigations in pursuing a CPS case and compiling evidence can take a while.

Im speculating on that of course.
 
Last edited:

I did a bit in U.K. law and criminal justice back in the early 00s when I lived there, admittedly more in Scotland (which is different from England), while I do a bit in the area in Ireland sadly still - over here I think the threory is similar but very unlikely for a case to proceed if an allegation isn’t made or a victim is hostile (doesn’t assist the investigation). Happy to admit Law in England is something I wouldn’t be able to apply ver batem or may have changed since I worked there, so happy to defer to lads who may be more up to date - I don’t live in the U.K. these days, so likely out of the loop.
Mate would you like the names of all the lads banned for fighting at football where nobody complained ? It’s a fairly long list like
 
Technically not, but in practice very unlikely the CPS would proceed with a case with DBB as a hostile witness.

Agreed if it’s a he said she said but directors box presumably full of witnesses and cctv , slam dunk assault charge .
 

Im not sure what you think I’m arguing mate?
Sorry don’t mean to come across as if I’m having a go , this story has just wound me up . I just sort of mean if you’re involved in an altercation in a ground you’re in trouble regardless of what anyone says . That’s the point I’m trying to make Also the club have a responsibility for supporter safety so I suggest are obliged to take action. .

I honestly think the story is absolute BS and will continue to think so until they prove me wrong which you’d think would be easy .
 
23 minutes later they made this response.







But took them 11 days to tell the world about a physical assault on an employee and that information isn't actually official. Just from "club sources" via a few journalists.

And not a bog standard employee and no offence to the good people that work at the club but the actual CEO
 
Agreed if it’s a he said she said but directors box presumably full of witnesses and cctv , slam dunk assault charge .

If the evidence is there definitely. If you are the police are you contacting the club in the morning to follow up on the allegations in the national media....

What strikes me as wired about it, is why leak it if there wasn’t any truth in it? Not saying there is, but it’s a very specific thing to leak - I mean you could just say there were death threats during the week and they are off the hook yesterday, having a women in headlock - is a madly graphic and specific if you were just looking for an easy out….

Someone posted something from the journo Richard Buxton this morning that said the police were “aware” of the incident - so I don’t know, maybe it was reported and they are investigating.
 
Sorry don’t mean to come across as if I’m having a go , this story has just wound me up . I just sort of mean if you’re involved in an altercation in a ground you’re in trouble regardless of what anyone says . That’s the point I’m trying to make Also the club have a responsibility for supporter safety so I suggest are obliged to take action. .

I honestly think the story is absolute BS and will continue to think so until they prove me wrong which you’d think would be easy .

Ah not at all mate, your grand, I’m just playing devils advocate as opposed to taking up the defence position - we’re all speculating.

In the case of football violence, who makes the case, the club, the Police, the victim - I’m not sure is it a CPS case or are people just banned by the club, do people go to prison like for throwing a haymakers at grounds.

Say the kid who Ronaldo smashed his phone, who took the case, the club, his parents or the police without either, I’m not 100% sure.

We’re not 100% sure it wasn’t reported, maybe it was and it’s being investigated and we just don’t know about it.
 
Last edited:

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top