To be fair on him, he has a really weak squad. Don't think any manager could do much. Especially with how poor we are in attack.
You could say that about any team who aren't doing well. It's not true.
Pickford is an England international.
Tarks is a good defender
Coady was in the England squad.
Patterson is young but was also one of the highest-rated young prospects in the country last year.
Gana is one of the better players in a decently ranked international team. He was playing for PSG last season.
Onana was one of the hottest young prospects in Europe and plays for one of the highest ranked international teams in the world.
Iwobi came to us as a regular starter in an Arsenal team that had just finished 5th and were runners-up in the Europa League.
Doucoure was highly sought after when he was at Watford and scored 17 goals in 3 seasons for them from midfield - not bad. He played at every level up to U-21 for France before opting for Mali because he couldn't quite get a place for the then World Champions.
Gordon was (allegedly) subject to bids of £40+ million last year.
Ignoring Dom, for obvious reasons, we're light in attack, which is a serious issue, but our team on paper is not worse than most of the division outside the top 7. You wouldn't actually swap our whole team (not the manager) for Fulham, Brighton, Bournemouth, Brentford, Palace or Leeds.
We have the 7th highest wage bill in the division. While not a perfect metric, it's the best single predictor of league position across all major leagues. You will struggle to find many teams in the whole of Europe who are underperforming as much as we are by that measure.
Where there are significant differences in wage bill compared with league position (i.e. 5+ league places), it's usually down to either (a) some structural issue, such as an FFP points deduction or (b) the manager.
If we had a manager who was achieving par with these players, we'd easily be mid-table.