Nil Satis Niasse Optimum
Player Valuation: £20m
You think we'd get 25m for McCarthy?If we end up selling McCarthy we'll get at least twice that fee, maybe more, so you could argue it might be good business to make a profit and get a player who does the same job who just had a far better season.
I've heard some Villa fans moan but that's the type of player that is really hard to judge, and I'd trust someone like Steve Walsh to make the right call over disillusioned and (rightfully) miserable fans of a team who have just been relegated.
I'd say between 10 - 15m.
Who is going to offer us twice the 13m we paid for him?! No chance!