Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

If Silva is sacked - who could/should we get?

Status
Not open for further replies.
evertonarntwe said:
would honestly rather have that fat mess sam rather than dyche, he is worse than him,

eddie howe has done amazing at Bournemouth but he should stay there, he tried going elsewhere and failed miserably, he;'s just one of them people suited to a club
Click to expand...

Agree with that, Dyche, Howe, Hodgson Fulham/Palace, etc

Moyes Everton?
 
blue to the bone said:
That will never manage us..
Click to expand...
Yeah, tough ask.

I'm not sure I would actually rave about him as manager, but would respect any success he could bring rather than be all Chelsea about it.

It is a no, though isn't it?

MOYES + CAHILL in understudy role would be my new favoured combo.

I think when clubs have had a sustained spell of success with a clear identity, there's no harm in tapping back into that.

It's working at Utd and I think it could work for us. Maybe 'Unsy' was a too much of a step up too soon, but I genuinely would love to see Moyes and favourite from that era back in the dug-out at Goodison for as long as we're there now. Feels like the most fitting close to what he achieved that they should see us into the new gaff.
 
smileychap said:
Agree with that, Dyche, Howe, Hodgson Fulham/Palace, etc

Moyes Everton?
Click to expand...

Moyes was suited to the Everton he walked into.

He isn't suited to a team/club actually looking to achieve more than being best of the rest.

Percentage football is too limited and he is too limited as a manager. You are just reaching for a comfort blanket in hard times.

Dyche is another percentage football manager. Extremely limited.

Howe....I honestly haven't a clue. Great achievement in solidifying Bournemouth in the top league but seems as capable of horrific runs of form as he is of getting surprise wins and solid runs during the season.

We need somebody to build with progressive football in mind. Not clean sheet and hope to grab a goal and the win. We need to think long term and not short term. We are stabilising after some terrible decisions over the last few years.

If it's not going to be Silva next season then we need somebody like that but better. Not absolute football dinosaurs like Moyes and Dyche.
 
smileychap said:
Yeah, tough ask.

I'm not sure I would actually rave about him as manager, but would respect any success he could bring rather than be all Chelsea about it.

It is a no, though isn't it?

MOYES + CAHILL in understudy role would be my new favoured combo.

I think when clubs have had a sustained spell of success with a clear identity, there's no harm in tapping back into that.

It's working at Utd and I think it could work for us. Maybe 'Unsy' was a too much of a step up too soon, but I genuinely would love to see Moyes and favourite from that era back in the dug-out at Goodison for as long as we're there now. Feels like the most fitting close to what he achieved that they should see us into the new gaff.
Click to expand...
If moyes came back to Everton I would be extremely annoyed and surprised.
He was a good fit in the past. But that's where he should remain
 
bicycleheader said:
Moyes was suited to the Everton he walked into.

He isn't suited to a team/club actually looking to achieve more than being best of the rest.

Percentage football is too limited and he is too limited as a manager. You are just reaching for a comfort blanket in hard times.

Dyche is another percentage football manager. Extremely limited.

Howe....I honestly haven't a clue. Great achievement in solidifying Bournemouth in the top league but seems as capable of horrific runs of form as he is of getting surprise wins and solid runs during the season.

We need somebody to build with progressive football in mind. Not clean sheet and hope to grab a goal and the win. We need to think long term and not short term. We are stabilising after some terrible decisions over the last few years.

If it's not going to be Silva next season then we need somebody like that but better. Not absolute football dinosaurs like Moyes and Dyche.
Click to expand...

Let's say you're right sir... but who?
 

smileychap said:
Let's say you're right sir... but who?
Click to expand...
Sam-Allardyce-697140.webp
 
TopBalconyView said:
View attachment 53712
Click to expand...
Yup, same points as Marco by this stage of the season... and that's factoring in Koeman's horror show.

I wouldn't want him back (Tosun and Wallcott haven't really fired either)... but would still value an up and coming British or 'Everton' man over Marco.

I note that through 'the mixer' of the mid-table merry go round we're about to arrive at our correct berth of best of the rest, which'll alleviate the pressure on mumbling fumbling silva.

For me, with cups gone, safety mostly assured and half the squad fit to leave IMHO, it's an ideal time for Brands to say to Marco play the kids. Let's really learn what value there over the next 5 months in our U21 & U23. Baningime, Davies, DCL, Dowell, Kenny fine - what about a few others. And FFS sell off all the deadwood of which there is a lot.
 

smileychap said:
Yup, same points as Marco by this stage of the season... and that's factoring in Koeman's horror show.

I wouldn't want him back (Tosun and Wallcott haven't really fired either)... but would still value an up and coming British or 'Everton' man over Marco.

I note that through 'the mixer' of the mid-table merry go round we're about to arrive at our correct berth of best of the rest, which'll alleviate the pressure on mumbling fumbling silva.

For me, with cups gone, safety mostly assured and half the squad fit to leave IMHO, it's an ideal time for Brands to say to Marco play the kids. Let's really learn what value there over the next 5 months in our U21 & U23. Baningime, Davies, DCL, Dowell, Kenny fine - what about a few others. And FFS sell off all the deadwood of which there is a lot.
Click to expand...
You are talking about Howe or Southgate?
 
This is a stupid idea. If he's sacked now it's utterly stupid.

If he's sacked at the end of the season a very different group of managers will be available.

Big Sam is available either way, so no worries there. LOL

As its hypothetical, I would go for Arteta or Eddie Howe, but what is the point really? If you are appointing a 30something or 40something, the only way to really test out the success is to give him 3 years, like we did with Martinez.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register
Back
Top