Is Wayne Rooney an Everton Legend

BainesontoastNEW · Friday at 2:18 PM

No. Not even up for debate, right? Carragher entertaining the thought sums him up completely.

RomanReigns · Friday at 2:18 PM

i don't think we will ever see a wayne rooney statue in liverpool so that should answer the question

McMagicT · Friday at 2:20 PM

The legends: DEAN , YOUNG & ROONEY.

I saw all three of them on the centre spot, Dean to kick off 60s game for his testimonial

GoldenToffee · Friday at 2:21 PM

Wtf - mad shout anybody using "Rooney" and "legend" in same sentence, unless "legend" is preceded with "not a".

Moomin · Friday at 2:23 PM

MikeH72 said:
But the question was whether you think Wayne Rooney is? And you randomly brought up how many trophies he’s won with a club that isn’t Everton?

I've no idea how many trophies he has won.

Goat · Friday at 2:25 PM

Moomin said:
I've no idea how many trophies he has won.

He hasnt won more than Everton.

GrandOldTeam · Friday at 2:26 PM

Added a poll for you.

Ged G · Friday at 2:27 PM

Miked1e said:
I would also agree with spitty....

THAT is not what anyone should ever do...

Ged G · Friday at 2:28 PM

Jacko93 said:
Unfortunately not. He could have been.

How could he have been? He was not gonna win anything with us

Ged G · Friday at 2:30 PM

Marc bolan said:
There is a discussion going on whether Rooney should be classed as a Everton legend
Carragher thinks not

Why is Carragher's opinion relevant?

johnjoeefc · Friday at 2:32 PM

Cult hero, icon but not legend. Didn't really show enough commitment or win anything etc to deserve legendary status. Don't think there are any legends in the last 30 years.

Ged G · Friday at 2:32 PM

Ste2018 said:
Rooney left as quickly as he could. He returned as late as he could. He won nothing with Everton.
Not an Everton legend

Consider this. If winning something helps makes one a legend, then we have NONE in many decades

Miked1e · Friday at 2:33 PM

Ged G said:
THAT is not what anyone should ever do...

Off to get a shower now....... clean myself.

Ged G · Friday at 2:34 PM

Miked1e said:
I would also agree with spitty....

Have your own opinion by all means but why agree with him? Why acknowledge him as some kind of benchmark?

Bedfordblue · Friday at 2:35 PM

Was sold to prevent us going into administration wasn’t he?
Does that grant legend status for single handedly securing the future of the club through his raw talent?