Transfer Rumour Jaden Philogene

[GrandOldSte117]

Is it wrong that I am quite encouraged that we are linked with this lad, as he clearly isn’t a Dyche type player, and more a thelwell/new manager type player?

Or am I reaching…..

Not as an insult or anything but I would say reaching.

Everton going for fringe player from a team above us is just par for the course.

 

[knowing your history]

Isn’t he the fella who comes on for villa and always gets booked for doing silly tackles

Got sent off at Fulham in a 15 minute sub cameo earlier this season.

 

[matty1878]

Bobble has now

bobble chats wobble

 

[matty1878]

Isn’t he the fella who comes on for villa and always gets booked for doing silly tackles

he won’t be coming on the pitch to play mate

 

[knowing your history]

Ndiaye wasn't a Dyche signing at all with how he actually plays.

The problem is that creative flair then gets lost in the defensive system and you're asking too much of that player to come up with match winning quality every game.

 

[peterw]

If Villa end up making a profit on him we'll look like a laughing stock once again. He was ours for the taking half a year ago, and hasn't played for them.

That said, he has huge potential and it's a good signing if we get him, lord knows do we need a bloody fast winger.

Injuries aside -he's been involved in the majority of games we've played this season. Or very close to it.

 

[NathDogg]

Ndiaye wasn't a Dyche signing at all with how he actually plays.

The problem is that creative flair then gets lost in the defensive system and you're asking too much of that player to come up with match winning quality every game.

Spot on mate.

Under Dyche, by the time illy has managed to dribble past half the opposition team to get close to their penalty box, he’s been fouled about 14 times (which the refs love to ignore for some reason) and is done in so loses the ball.

All the above is after he’s tracked back to win the ball back for the 15th time, after doucs or Harrison have given it away cheaply yet again.

I’ve just put young philogene right off from joining us haven’t I, sorry lads….

 

[peterw]

A friend who is a season ticket holder, mentioned that he has struggled since his return and has been sidelined recently due to criticism from the Villa fans. He believe that he has incredible ability, but his lack of end product and mental resilience seem to be holding him back. Finished with, under Dyche he will be awful.

He was sidelined due to injury and then lack of form. I doubt Emery would drop a player because a few fans were critical of him.

 

[JJK]

Concerning that Thelwell doesn’t change targets. To me it screams he doesn’t ever have a plan B.

 

[mikel_88]

Concerning that Thelwell doesn’t change targets. To me it screams he doesn’t ever have a plan B.

Will if he gets fixated and does another gnonto all window, i dont mind deals like this if the player is aveilable but also got to kno when to walk away.

 

[whiteshadow]

Don't see the point in signing him if we're sticking with Dyche as he just won't use him properly as he doesn't 'track' back enough.

If we played 'normal' football I think he'd be a great singing.

 

[Nymzee]

Concerning that Thelwell doesn’t change targets. To me it screams he doesn’t ever have a plan B.

But this guy was Plan A, and we didn't get him, so do we need a Plan B here?

 

[buededw1]

He was sidelined due to injury and then lack of form. I doubt Emery would drop a player because a few fans were critical of him.

That's what he said, it was a mixture of reasons.

 

[goldfinchmule]

Can he receive, protect and pass a ball along the floor to another player ?

If he can we will soon knock that out of him,otherwise he wont fit in.

 

[S of S]

Potter type signing…….?