James McCarthy

[Millea]

Technically he's so poor. It's actually mental how loose his first touch is at times. He looks scared to play a forward pass because it's like he knows he can't.

Fed up with him now to be honest.

Fed up with Everton.

 

[Goat]

haha lighten up will you. I am a fan of his but found it baffling to start championing him for a start after one of the worst first half showings I have seen this season.

If you think ANYBODY comes away from that Arsenal game with any credit you watched a different game.

So no, I wont lighten up, I suggest you find a different scapegoat tho.

 

[bluestevon]

If you think ANYBODY comes away from that Arsenal game with any credit you watched a different game.

So no, I wont lighten up, I suggest you find a different scapegoat tho.

Only ones IMO to come out with any credit are the fans for not walking out after the first half

 

[Millea]

Don't attack Goats lover please thanks x

 

[bluewally]

And you felt the best way to combat it is to attack his amazingly talented team mate.

Interesting.

Have we seen enough to start calling him amazingly talented?

They are different players.

McCarthy breaks up play thats his role. He doesnt need to offer anything else.

I also think he's unfairly judged in a period where he's expected to do the running for two players as Barry for all his gifts just doesnt have the legs anymore

 

[Goat]

Only ones IMO to come out with any credit are the fans for not walking out after the first half

I had to watch the 2nd half stunned that he took Besic off to play 3 at the back.

Never in all my years watching Everton has a manger made a worse sub.

 

[bluewally]

I had to watch the 2nd half stunned that he took Besic off to play 3 at the back.

Never in all my years watching Everton has a manger made a worse sub.

He had to shoehorn stones in somewhere.

 

[Goat]

Have we seen enough to start calling him amazingly talented?

They are different players.

McCarthy breaks up play thats his role. He doesnt need to offer anything else.

I also think he's unfairly judged in a period where he's expected to do the running for two players as Barry for all his gifts just doesnt have the legs anymore

Ive seen enough yes, I watch most of his games for Bosnia, where he runs games from the midfield and often outshines Pranjic.

 

[chazzle_dazzle]

Have we seen enough to start calling him amazingly talented?

They are different players.

McCarthy breaks up play thats his role. He doesnt need to offer anything else.

I also think he's unfairly judged in a period where he's expected to do the running for two players as Barry for all his gifts just doesnt have the legs anymore

I think he is talented - but i think he is overrated by certain sections of the fans considering his game time.

Does he offer more then McCarthy - i would say he does, his engine is not close to McCarthy but his all round play appears much better. But the cat that got on the pitch would offer more then McCarthy at the moment.

 

[Millea]

Have we seen enough to start calling him amazingly talented?

They are different players.

McCarthy breaks up play thats his role. He doesnt need to offer anything else.

I also think he's unfairly judged in a period where he's expected to do the running for two players as Barry for all his gifts just doesnt have the legs anymore

You at least expect him to kick off an attack from time to time instead of just pass it to a centre half week in week out.

 

[bluestevon]

I had to watch the 2nd half stunned that he took Besic off to play 3 at the back.

Never in all my years watching Everton has a manger made a worse sub.

For me mate Smith had a fair few ones that left me gobsmacked, but think the West Ham game i will never ever get over the sheer headscratching after that one

 

[raithrovers94]

When Barry signed I thought McCarthy would improve lost his way a bit but feel he will come good

 

[Goat]

For me mate Smith had a fair few ones that left me gobsmacked, but think the West Ham game i will never ever get over the sheer headscratching after that one

Never seen an Everton Manager admit defeat with 45minutes left in a game.

 

[bluewally]

Ive seen enough yes, I watch most of his games for Bosnia, where he runs games from the midfield and often outshines Pranjic.

I've seen a lot but most of them aren't against top opposition. Saw him against Ireland I think and he was pretty anonymous.

Dont get me wrong he's got potential but he's raw and hasnt gotten nearly enough game time in the prem.

Messi is amazingly talented. He's a long way from that

 

[NiasseandLukaku]

niasse for Lennon against WHU?

 

[Goat]

I've seen a lot but most of them aren't against top opposition. Saw him against Ireland I think and he was pretty anonymous.

Dont get me wrong he's got potential but he's raw and hasnt gotten nearly enough game time in the prem.

Messi is amazingly talented. He's a long way from that

Messi is a jarg little midget playing in a 2 team league.

Dont compare Gods to Jokers.