James McCarthy

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dunphy watches motd highlights so I'd swerve his opinion on any pl player. Was slating him couple of years back when he was one of our best players at the time.


Fair enough - as I said thought his criticism of him was harsh at the time but think I see the same sorts of faults that he pointed out. Ireland have used him wrongly though. He is a defensive mid and trying to play him as anything other is a waste of what he does best.
 

Fair enough - as I said thought his criticism of him was harsh at the time but think I see the same sorts of faults that he pointed out. Ireland have used him wrongly though. He is a defensive mid and trying to play him as anything other is a waste of what he does best.
Was very good for us when When didn't play and he wad the dm
 


Thought he was going to be a really good player for us, following his first season. But right now he is being kept out by players who are playing better. I would of thought he'd be happy to stay with Barry being the age he is, surely he can't play every match. Besic is out for months, surely there is a place for him unless we're bringing in another player in that position?

Surely he could of got his head down and let the new manager coach him to play the way he wants? If he was upset about being brought off before half time? Well he was out of position and isn't expected to be a world class right back. Best let him go, maybe we can do some interesting wheeling dealing?
 
I've never been a huge fan. I get what he brings to the team when he's on song but he's just a bit limited for me.

No tears shed on my part if he was to move on. Shame Martinez didn't go to a club side because he'd probably have given us £25m for the lad.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top