Jarrad Branthwaite

Status
Not open for further replies.
My biggest ? On this guy is can he stay healthy in this league? I feel like every time we see him he is getting hurt. I see the potential but he rarely could stay fit when he was here and never got to have a run in the team. I’d like to see him play ffs
 

My biggest ? On this guy is can he stay healthy in this league? I feel like every time we see him he is getting hurt. I see the potential but he rarely could stay fit when he was here and never got to have a run in the team. I’d like to see him play ffs

Think it's just an Everton thing, we injure everyone. Even Gbamin is staying fit away from us.
 
Think it's just an Everton thing, we injure everyone. Even Gbamin is staying fit away from us.
Once Everton touches you I guess. It could be that they have to work 10 times harder in our backline too. We just have bad luck with debilitating injuries.
 
Why do I keep reading that we have named our price for him. He shouldn't be for sale. He should be given an opportunity to see if he can make the step up to the Prem full time. I think he can/will. These types of players should be the ones we are looking for going forward.

Sadly I don't think this is quite as clear cut as you might think - if we're still sailing very close to the margin of the P+L rules (and we might not be to be fair, the P+L investigation seems to relate to the reporting of prior transfer windows), £35m for Branthwaite would allow us to do far more than £50m for Onana because of the cheap fee/contract we paid for young Jarrad.

Moreover, are we really sure that Branthwaite can come in and replace Mina? I'd like to think that he could given a full preseason, perhaps even a dedicated defensive midfielder ahead of him and Tarkowski, but I can understand why the club might want a CB who has performed well in a stronger league than the Netherlands (whom you can probably acquire for, what, £20m? Half of what you get for Branthwaite). The rest of the dough then goes on a forward or fullbacks, both typically being more expensive than CBs.

Players like Branthwaite certainly are the ones we should be looking for going forward, but by extension, the club needs to get far, far better at striking while the iron is hot and selling whilst prices are high - it's not hard to imagine Branthwaite coming into this side and struggling having been in a mostly dominant PSV team and knocking a few £m off of his price tag.

Personally - I really hope we don't sell him, and I hope we've got more money in the transfer kitty than I think we actually do; but I can't say it would surprise me if it did happen, and I think he'd go on to be another casualty of our decade of mismanagement (Stones, Deulofeu, Barkley, Lukaku etc)
 

Hope Dyche likes him. It will be triple blow if it turns out otherwise.

We can’t afford to let Branthwaite sit in the bench, devalue and refuse to sign a new contract while his favourite keane keeps playing and conceding loads of goals.
 
Hope Dyche likes him. It will be triple blow if it turns out otherwise.

We can’t afford to let Branthwaite sit in the bench, devalue and refuse to sign a new contract while his favourite keane keeps playing and conceding loads of goals.

….I think that’s a bit unfair on Dyche. He ultimately wasn’t blinkered to include Keane once he identified Mina as the better option. He even discarded him for Coady in that final key game. One thing we’ve learned about Dyche is he isn’t stupid.

I entirely agree about Branthwaite, I think he has huge potential. Was speaking to somebody close to him this morning, James Vaughan has certainly been watching him this season so surely very positive reports have come back.
 
We either need to play him and hopefully he develops more to become to a top defender.

Or sell him while value is high
 
Did PSV not want to exercise their right to throw us an offer? I heard a couple months ago that was the case.. now it sounds like they're not going to? unless it turns out that we've priced them out.
 

We are the perfect club for him right now. Rio Ferdinand was still nowhere near even joining Leeds at his age. Spurs were still playing Sol Campbell up front and at full back at this point.

Playing alongside Tarkowski will be great for him.
 
Did PSV not want to exercise their right to throw us an offer? I heard a couple months ago that was the case.. now it sounds like they're not going to? unless it turns out that we've priced them out.
I would imagine it will be price.
I don't really see any big teams looking at him yet, so if Dyche offers him first team football, I think we will see him stay
 
Did PSV not want to exercise their right to throw us an offer? I heard a couple months ago that was the case.. now it sounds like they're not going to? unless it turns out that we've priced them out.


Theyve said several times (as well as Dutch journalists) that they cant afford what were asking.
 
I would hope we’d give him a new contract and he’d be a first team regular next season. Think he has great potential. After a year playing in the premier league we’d get a much higher fee for him than if we sold him now.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top