sw blue
Player Valuation: £6m
Didn't he score that with his feet? Hope my memory isn't going at 36!
Jarrad Branthwaite
- Thread starter Cjplennon
- Start date
- Status
NathDogg
Player Valuation: £50m
I wouldn’t have loaned him out tbh, but I’m glad that he seems to be getting lots of football and doing well.
He was ahead of Keane, holgate and Mina for me in the pecking order and I would have started him with Tarkowski - I don’t think we needed coady.
A hell of a lot regarding who stays and who goes will depend on our league status come seasons end.
If we go down this lad will be cashed in on, sadly.
If he’s back in the squad next season, he starts for me.
He was ahead of Keane, holgate and Mina for me in the pecking order and I would have started him with Tarkowski - I don’t think we needed coady.
A hell of a lot regarding who stays and who goes will depend on our league status come seasons end.
If we go down this lad will be cashed in on, sadly.
If he’s back in the squad next season, he starts for me.
No they don't
Cmonefcsortitout!
Player Valuation: £5m
Stop selling young, promising players. Or we will never become good, it’s as simple as that imo.
Saint Domingo
Player Valuation: £90m
Is this a piece of good Everton recruitment? Just wondering…
It can work if we are clever with the money we make. Keep in mind the season we sold Rooney, we got into the champions league. I agree it would be great to keep some promising young players but saying to completely "stop" seems irresponsible. Just my take.
Cmonefcsortitout!
Player Valuation: £5m
What you’re saying does make sense, but we have spent terribly in general. I think we would be better trying to develop our young players. We normally replace them with players who aren’t as good, and cost more money. It’s hard for us to sign top level replacements, as they normally have more appealing alternatives. If we keep prospects, we might improve, and they might improve, and we can then sell for more in the future.
GoldenToffee
Player Valuation: £70m
If he's worth £20m then surely Brands will sanction a £45m bid.
I mean we've sold a lot who have proven to be nothing but promising and have dwindled down the leagues so idk
I'm of the opposite opinion. I think a loan was the only real option. One of the top teams in skillful league. He'll learn so much from this loan. If he was at Everton, with our current form, all the protest's etc it could of had a bad impact on his development.
Spadge Vernacular
Player Valuation: £70m
If we sell this lad and keep Keane it'd be peak Moshing.
I understand what you are saying, but think of it like this:
We've spent little to nothing on the youth player coming though. They become desired and anything we make is a profit. We then use that money to buy good player and/or reinvest in youth to ensure growth in the academy (resulting on more promising youth, hence more revenue or prospects). We shouldn't sell all our youth and I'm not saying we should sell branthwaite, but it can be smart to sell young players sometimes. Though i understand we don't want to sell all our young players
samcdavies94
Player Valuation: £8m
A lot depends on the player himself with two years left on his contract in the summer, but the plan really should be to give an extension with a bit of a pay increase, give him minutes next season and be prepared to sell in the next couple of seasons.
Obviously, in an ideal world the quality of the team would grow as Branthwaite does, but we usually don't.
Obviously, in an ideal world the quality of the team would grow as Branthwaite does, but we usually don't.
Hopefully he can take Minas squad spot.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
