2022/23 Kevin Thelwell

[windymiller]

Comparing team honours when comparing individual players doesn't tell the whole story.
It's like saying someone like Le Tissier is trash because he didn't when anything, when he was better than other players who had lots of team honours.

Fair point. Sheedy was still better. I think a lot of fans think football started in 1992.

 

[windymiller]

I'm not criticising Sheedy, he was great, but using his team accomplishments in a team game to claim he was better is a bit harsh
Djimi Traore has a champions league medal

Comparing Sheedy with Djimi Traore is the harshest thing I've ever seen!

 

[Eggs]

How is it his fault DCL got injured?

….it was openly discussed on here how fragile DCL had become so leaving the squad with only Rondon as back-up carried significant risk. Sadly that risk has materialised. Rondon wasn’t even selected when available, so the club went into a PL season with just one capable striker.

Criticism is certainly valid.

 

[rochdaleblue]

How is it his fault DCL got injured?

It is his fault, that we only had two forwards worthy of the name on our books and one was sold 7 weeks ago and not replaced. No club only has one striker on its books, let alone a striker who suffered terribly with injuries last season. Fail to prepare, prepare to fail should be our DOF’s motto.

 

[davek]

If we lose 9 points from opening 3 games this feller is on a slippery slope.

 

[4737carlin]

It is his fault, that we only had two forwards worthy of the name on our books and one was sold 7 weeks ago and not replaced. No club only has one striker on its books, let alone a striker who suffered terribly with injuries last season. Fail to prepare, prepare to fail should be our DOF’s motto.

All good thigs to those who wait, its been a good window so far with a lot of work to do, and still some to be done

 

[4737carlin]

If we lose 9 points from opening 3 games this feller is on a slippery slope.

Un doing the mess Brands made isnt going to be done in one summer

 

[rochdaleblue]

All good thigs to those who wait, its been a good window so far with a lot of work to do, and still some to be done

We’ve thrown away the chance of 6 points already, another potential victory could slip away if we don’t get a forward in for Saturday. It is disgraceful it really is.

 

[bluesb1970]

If we lose 9 points from opening 3 games this feller is on a slippery slope.

Tosh.

 

[4737carlin]

We’ve thrown away the chance of 6 points already, another potential victory could slip away if we don’t get a forward in for Saturday. It is disgraceful it really is.

But he could of thrown all focus on a striker and not got the defenders, we have so much to do right now its unfair to have expected it all to have been done allready

 

[Billy Dean]

A bit simplistic to blame solely the DOF for the striker situation IMO

 

[Preki]

I don't think Sheedy won the FA cup, did he?

84?

 

[MikeH72]

How is it his fault DCL got injured?

It’s his fault that our alternative to DCL is Salomon Rondon.

 

[windymiller]

84?

Sheedy didn't play. Injured.

 

[Preki]

Sheedy didn't play. Injured.

Still counts surely?