Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
- Status
Lloydystark
Player Valuation: £35m
Can't believe Holgates boyfriend hasn't commented on here yet saying how he's the bees knees and keane is a oaf
Sell one, keep the rest.
ZissouBlue
Player Valuation: £8m
There is a lot of yo-yo ing on players on this site (obviously) but I don't really get it for Mina. He still makes the occasional error that makes you shake your head, but honestly he has done a great job cutting that out of his game. Think he's underrated due to the injuries at this point. We are a lot more reliable week to week with him in the lineup and the results speak for themselves this season.
I'm not saying he's a Funes Mori like, and I love watching Mina play, but I don't think anyone (himself included) has any idea what he's going to do with the ball. Maybe unpredictable is better than error prone, but you ideally want something like a synergy of thought and effort with your backline sometimes I wonder if you can get that with Mina.
Stuartisitc1878
Player Valuation: £30m
He's the closest thing we have to a leader at the back. I think people confuse his gangly awkwardness with being poor. Keane, Holgate and Godfrey all look better beside him which says it all. Sadly he just can't put a decent run of games together.
I think Carlo will want to bring in his own defender, someone he considers captain material so one of Keane or Mina will go and I'd prefer it to be Keane but i think Mina is a more sellable asset and we have too many players we can't rely on due to recurring injuries.
More to what you said above (or maybe it was someone else), if he wasn't injured so much maybe we'd have the impression that he was rock solid at the back. It's very easy to conflate one the of unreliability for another. I love Yerry, just not certain he's part of the solution (he's no Gbmain, but still). I agree his leadership is valuable, but I don't see him as a club captain center back type, and that's what we need to add IMO (unless Godfrey is that type).
If someone came for Mina with a reasonable offer, do you take it?
Papa Shango
Player Valuation: £70m
Depends if we can line up someone else to replace him.
He is our best centre back. They all have flaws but he has less of them.
Stuartisitc1878
Player Valuation: £30m
i wouldn't be surprised if Carlo tries to bring in a former player whether that's some sort of part exchange with Napoli for Koulibaly or offering someone like Jerome Boateng or even Sergio Ramos (he's a free agent right?) a decent 1 year contract. I hope that's not the case but i do think he likes a bit of experience at the back.
I agree, he's not a captain, he's not that leader we need.
Kantareller
Player Valuation: £35m
I'd counter with they can get Keane for that offer instead.
paulbefc
Player Valuation: £60m
The only two we should consider selling are Mina and Holgate.
Holgate because he could fetch a decent fee and still in his mid-20s hasn't hit the required level yet and Mina because of his wages and contract situation - not any lack of ability. Keane is a good player and probably won't attract the kind of fee he's worth anyway.
I'd be tempted to keep the 4 of them and loan Branthwaite out again as we're not in Europe, but if we think we could attract a serious player and need to operate a one-in-one-out policy to raise the funds, we'll need to sell one.
Holgate because he could fetch a decent fee and still in his mid-20s hasn't hit the required level yet and Mina because of his wages and contract situation - not any lack of ability. Keane is a good player and probably won't attract the kind of fee he's worth anyway.
I'd be tempted to keep the 4 of them and loan Branthwaite out again as we're not in Europe, but if we think we could attract a serious player and need to operate a one-in-one-out policy to raise the funds, we'll need to sell one.
- Status