Luke Garbutt

Try to keep him, or let him leave ?

  • Total voters
    308
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

mikeh72 said:
"Of Everton's quality". How good do you think we are mate, we're 10th? And maybe he won't, maybe he'll join someone like West Brom or Palace, and develop as a Premier League player. How could that possibly harm his development more than getting splinters in his arse here?

He offered us much more of an attacking outlet, boundless energy and deadly set piece delivery. Looked very much like a Baines of 4 years ago. So remind me again what Oviedo has done?
Click to expand...
Been our best LB last season, actually show love for the shirt and get his head down and work hard.
 
Shame he looks to be off.

But if he wants game time he won't be getting it instead of Baines, so what can you do?
 

I have an awful feeling he's doing the same as Moyes did. If so, then bugger him. Moyes' story didn't quite pan out the way he expected; no great reason to think that Garbutt will move and automatically become a world beater.
 
formerly manx toffee said:
sign him for 4 years and loan him to Bournemouth
Click to expand...

I think this would be an ideal scenario, get him to sign a long term contract, loan him to a newly promoted team for a year or two if Baines continues to stay at the same level an then bring him back into the first team picture as Baines gets towards the end of his career.

He could look at this way, dislodge Baines from our 11, and have a big chance of becoming England left back. The opportunity is there for him, he just has to stay patient.
 
I'd be quite confident in saying Garbutt is better than Baines was at the same age. Give him a dwal and see what happens because no doubt when Baines is finished we'll go and spend money on the same type of player.
 

mikeh72 said:
Don't let your vendetta against him for his post-Newcastle tweet get in the way of sense, Dave. That sentence is utter rubbish
Click to expand...
Why is it rubbish?

What do you think he's doing that's an alternative explanation which makes his stance so much more noble?

I'd be interested to know. It cant be lack of game time because he's leapfrogged Oviedo in the second half of the season on that score, and I dont see Oviedo looking to walk away.
 
davek said:
Why is it rubbish?

What do you think he's doing that's an alternative explanation which makes his stance so much more noble?

I'd be interested to know. It cant be lack of game time because he's leapfrogged Oviedo in the second half of the season on that score, and I dont see Oviedo looking to walk away.
Click to expand...

You heartless git. Bry can hardly walk at all right now.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top