Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2020/21 Marcel Brands

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because again, there is no evidence of Ancelotti working at a club without a DoF.

Manager's picking players just for themselves is ultra short term thinking.
So if you ask Carlo what right back he’d like for x amount you don’t think he could come up with a name because he’s always worked with a dof? Do me a favour. Managers picking players has worked in English football for 99% of its history and it seemed to work. You still have a scouting system to assist the manager.
A manager lives and dies by the clubs signings. Carlo is being hampered if Brands is picking players too. If his track record was good we wouldn’t be having this conversation.
 
So if you ask Carlo what right back he’d like for x amount you don’t think he could come up with a name because he’s always worked with a dof? Do me a favour. Managers picking players has worked in English football for 99% of its history and it seemed to work. You still have a scouting system to assist the manager.
A manager lives and dies by the clubs signings. Carlo is being hampered if Brands is picking players too. If his track record was good we wouldn’t be having this conversation.

I never said he couldn't do it but again, it's short term. What if he buys a specific RB for his system, he leaves/get's sacked next year and a new manager comes in thinking "I want the complete opposite type of full-back to this lad".
 

Because again, there is no evidence of Ancelotti working at a club without a DoF.

Manager's picking players just for themselves is ultra short term thinking.
Did he have a DoF when he was at Chelsea?

That and Marcel will at least spend some time finding a bunch of players that meet the criteria of a certain position that Carlo is looking at.
That way Carlo can look at a bunch of different players before making a final decision.
 
I never said he couldn't do it but again, it's short term. What if he buys a specific RB for his system, he leaves/get's sacked next year and a new manager comes in thinking "I want the complete opposite type of full-back to this lad".
What is the point in two people picking players when one has shown he’s useless at it?
 
I never said he couldn't do it but again, it's short term. What if he buys a specific RB for his system, he leaves/get's sacked next year and a new manager comes in thinking "I want the complete opposite type of full-back to this lad".
We've gone from Martinez's "retain possession at all costs" to Koemans "grock in the middle" to Silva's "..." I genuinely don't know to Carlo's. How is that not just ripping up the blueprints every time?
 
Ripped jeans wearing weapon.

Screen Shot 2021-03-13 at 20.44.37.png
 

What is the point in two people picking players when one has shown he’s useless at it?

I don't think you're grasping this whole long-term strategy I'm going for here.

Doucoure was picked by Brands, Ancelotti hadn't heard of him, he liked the pick, we bought the player, it works.

All the players Brands is slated for signing came when he was picking people for Silva's needs.
 
The best thing hat can happen to this club is for him not to sign a new deal. Digne is the only decent signing he’s made IMO. It baffles me how some players get so much praise that are just very average.

Mina has been a good buy as well, Godfrey one of our best in years and Doucoure (Carlo admits he'd never seen him before) has been so, so important. Kean we'll likely make a profit on so that's good business.

He's had far more hits than misses, that's undeniable.
 
Godfrey has been our best buy in years. Mina has been a good buy as well, so has Doucoure (Carlo admits he'd never seen him before). Kean we'll likely make a profit on so that's good business.

He's had far more hits than misses, that's undeniable.
Mina is an average signing for the fee.

Brands was aware of Doucoure because of Silva.

What a great talent spotter. Finds players by watching the world cup and speaking to the old manager.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top