Marco Silva

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mozza1987 said:
Sorry mate but Poch has been brilliant since coming over. Are you honestly going to say Ferguson stunk the place out in his first season after what he achieved? Poch didn’t have loads of money. Ferguson never to begin with. Wenger never had tons and look what he achieved. If you don’t take a risk sometimes then you miss out on these managers.
Click to expand...
But he did. So the message is that even a great can fail here. There'd be no leeway offered a lesser manager like Fonseca if he did the same.
 

meagher94 said:
Just beat me!

@roydo



For the record he lost his only Carabao Cup game against Bristol, then won his only FA Cup game against Bristol again.
Click to expand...

I'd like to add, both city sides were 'weakened' sides.

Especially the fa cup game where we fielded a few youngsters as it was sandwiched between (or close to)our league cup run.
 
People need to back the new man and stop arguing about him. The alternative of keeping Fat Sam is dreadful. Silva might surprise or he might fail - that is the beauty of the game of football.
 
dinverro said:
People need to back the new man and stop arguing about him. The alternative of keeping Fat Sam is dreadful. Silva might surprise or he might fail - that is the beauty of the game of football.
Click to expand...
They will back him once he is here, because they have no choice, but that dosent mean going for Silva isn't a wasted opporunity.
It will be a pathetic move from Moshiri, it will be him that questions now need asking about.
 
Silva issue from the rumour mill was that he talked to players about bringing them with him to Everton. They talked about it and then the deal never went through. Players and managers morale hits the floor. Watford had to probably sack him.
 

Last season Silva was a manager about Watfords level. On leaving Watford half way through the season, he showed nothing to suggest he is above that level.
I am ok with him coming, but it doesnt strike me as a message from the board that there is vast amounts of money swishing about to make next season any different from whats gone before
 
davek said:
But he did. So the message is that even a great can fail here. There'd be no leeway offered a lesser manager like Fonseca if he did the same.
Click to expand...
But he didn’t fail though did he? One bad season doesn’t change how brilliant he was. It clearly shows managers with no premier league experience can do great jobs. I named many. Yes some had a larger budget but others didn’t. Sometimes you have to take a risk.
 

When Martinez obviously wins the W/C with Belgium, mosh will realise his mistake in sacking him and employ him on a 1 year £20 mill contract ....:cool::cool::cool::cool:. What...A ...Manager,.
 

Attachments

  • kevs nappy.webp
    kevs nappy.webp
    5.1 KB · Views: 67
Kev The Rat said:
Pellegrini odds on for West Ham

And yet moshiri stuck on this joker.

Absolutely disgusting.
Click to expand...

Wouldn't go as far as to say "disgusting", If we had got him when we originally went in for him there would not have been much dissent amongst fans.

People didn't want to give Martinez a chance, look what he did in his first season, won us the clubs historical 72 point trophy.

Whilst I am not overjoyed, he has decent pedigree. we can't cherry pick on his management career, either judge it as a whole or not at all. He hasn't just managed Hull and Watford.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top