Because his first seven years here were a big success. It's easy to forget the position we were in before he arrived but to put it mildly was grim. He took a club that with the exception of the Joe Royle years had been awful and relegation fodder since the inception of the premier league. He turned the club around and gave us our self respect back thay had beem desimated after years of dross. He made us the best of the rest, gave us three of our four best league seasons of the Premier League era and reached a cup final (which he admittedly bottled). His following four years were clearly not as good as what had come before and it was obvious things were going stale but they never even got close to the miserable dross of the last two season's under the fraud who followed him here. Id happily take Moyes over Martinez any day, though I sudder at the thought of being stuck with one of them!