Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Next manager discussion (poll reset 21/05/2016)

Who would you want?

  • Frank de Boer

    Votes: 302 17.0%
  • David Moyes

    Votes: 56 3.2%
  • Manuel Pellegrini

    Votes: 152 8.6%
  • Ronald Koeman

    Votes: 286 16.1%
  • Other (please state below)

    Votes: 109 6.1%
  • Unai Emery

    Votes: 870 49.0%

  • Total voters
    1,775
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Give up the Jose dream lads, Van Gaal is speaking like a man who knows.
WpR4D.gif
 
Forget about de Boer, forget about Mourinho, forget about Moyes, forget about Pellegrini and forget about Koeman.

Only one man who should be considered for the role of Everton manager, and that man is Lucien Favre.

One of the most underrated managers in world football, has succeeded everywhere he's been, some people yap on about a lack of premier league experience. Let me tell you, Favre would make a mockery of this league.

Only concern is language skills maybe, and he has probably the lowest tolerance level in relation to the media, like the lowest I've ever seen, may be a problem coming to England.

Based on what though? why would he make a mockery of this league?

I have heard that about plenty of managers, few have succeeded.
 
Ok, in light of mucho research, my new and improved list is ready to be released to the public :

1. Cocu
2. Favre
3. Koeman
4. Frank De Boer

I have removed Emery out of respect for his game tonight, if he wins he can go into the number 2 slot, if he loses, he can get right in the bin.


Im astounded you have FDB below Favre and Koeman.

You have disappointed me.

Greatly.
 
An overview of Favre I posted on another forum which I think might be relevant and may get you guys excited:

Favre took Echallens to the highest they've been in the Swiss league structure, took a Yverdon-Sport team strugglng at the bottom of second division Swiss football to promotion and managed to guide them to a 5th place finish in their first year in the top flight of Swiss football, their best finish to date, won the Swiss Cup with Servette and took them to the R16 of the UEFA Cup, guided FC Zurich to their first league title in 25 years, took Hertha Berlin to a 4th place finish in only his second season there whilst only having the 13th biggest budget in the entire league, took Gladbach from the brink of relegation and guided them towards survival THEN managed to take the exact just about the same starting 11, which had almost got relegated the season before, to a 4th place finish and they steadily consolidated themselves in the higher echelons of German football for the rest of the time he was there.

His record when it comes to molding younger players as well as improving players in general is not too shabby. I remember Dante was the joke of the Bundesliga for a while but then a season and a half later he wound up being bought by Bayern where he played an important role in leading them to a CL win, and who could forget how formidable he made Reus look.
 

An overview of Favre I posted on another forum which I think might be relevant and may get you guys excited:

Favre took Echallens to the highest they've been in the Swiss league structure, took a Yverdon-Sport team strugglng at the bottom of second division Swiss football to promotion and managed to guide them to a 5th place finish in their first year in the top flight of Swiss football, their best finish to date, won the Swiss Cup with Servette and took them to the R16 of the UEFA Cup, guided FC Zurich to their first league title in 25 years, took Hertha Berlin to a 4th place finish in only his second season there whilst only having the 13th biggest budget in the entire league, took Gladbach from the brink of relegation and guided them towards survival THEN managed to take the exact just about the same starting 11, which had almost got relegated the season before, to a 4th place finish and they steadily consolidated themselves in the higher echelons of German football for the rest of the time he was there.

His record when it comes to molding younger players as well as improving players in general is not too shabby. I remember Dante was the joke of the Bundesliga for a while but then a season and a half later he wound up being bought by Bayern where he played an important role in leading them to a CL win, and who could forget how formidable he made Reus look.

Swiss football doesnt excite me
 
IMO there is more questions over Favre as there is over Koeman.

What Favre done was impressive but it was the Bundesliga, people where slating it the other day when i mentioned Bayern had bought Mendes and Hummels. People saying that De Boer has question marks because he hasn't done it in the prem - its just the same isn't it.

Koeman, while defo isn't my first choice, has improved Southampton year on year he has been there.

You can't compare the Eredevisie with the Bundesliga. The Bundesliga is only just below the Prem in quality. And De Boer won it with the biggest club in the country when most of his rivals fell apart - Favre wildly overperformed with a hugely underfunded/unfashionable team.

Im warming to him, just something in my head keeps saying no.

Cant put my finger on it yet.

Might be the Shane Long for 12m or the 1 win in 10 from earlier on in the season and the meek cup exits.

You're going to hate me for this but I think Long for 12m to Southampton was a genuinely decent buy.

*hides*
 
1-- Mourinho
2-- De Boer / Cocu

That's my current shortlist.

Koeman = Dutch Moyes
Emery = Not won an away game all season
Favre = Lost 5 games on the spin and jumped ship.

On Emery, he has Sergio Rico in goal whose just off De Gea level...would love us to sign him. World class.
 
Based on what though? why would he make a mockery of this league?

I have heard that about plenty of managers, few have succeeded.

The premier league is dross tactically, managers who have struggled in different countries go to England and do just fine.

Pochetinno, Ranieri, Sanches Flores to name a few had spotty records before making their way to England where they've done just fine.

England is tactically regressive, to the extent that innovative managers from the continent can slot in and do fantastically well.
 

You can't compare the Eredevisie with the Bundesliga. The Bundesliga is only just below the Prem in quality. And De Boer won it with the biggest club in the country when most of his rivals fell apart - Favre wildly overperformed with a hugely underfunded/unfashionable team.



You're going to hate me for this but I think Long for 12m to Southampton was a genuinely decent buy.

*hides*


We dont know if FDB would have done a better job in a different club but he took Ajax with a much lower wage bill than others like AZ and Twente to the first league trophy..likewise Cocu now.

A good manager in Holland could well be a good manager in germany..vice versa.

Who knows if they would be decent here....no one.

Look at Wenger in Japan.
 
You can't compare the Eredevisie with the Bundesliga. The Bundesliga is only just below the Prem in quality. And De Boer won it with the biggest club in the country when most of his rivals fell apart - Favre wildly overperformed with a hugely underfunded/unfashionable team.



You're going to hate me for this but I think Long for 12m to Southampton was a genuinely decent buy.

*hides*

No i agree about that - i rate the Bundesliga, always have - yet people where saying it was a joke the other day when i was talking about it.

I just think there is as many questions about Favre as everyone else at the moment. Including the mental aspect of quitting because he lost 5 games
 
Its an ever changing list, the fact that Frank makes it should make him happy.

And I honestly keep forgetting about Sammy Lee, so lets switch them round.

1. Cocu
2. Favre
3. Frank De Boer
4. Koeman

Happy now Zat?


No mourinho?

How is Favre higher than FDB ?
 
The premier league is dross tactically, managers who have struggled in different countries go to England and do just fine.

Pochetinno, Ranieri, Sanches Flores to name a few had spotty records before making their way to England where they've done just fine.

England is tactically regressive, to the extent that innovative managers from the continent can slot in and do fantastically well.

The other thing thats maybe concerning me a bit, is he left after 5 games - gave an excuse of not being able to take them further. How come he hasn't gone back in somewhere? there has been plenty of jobs come up.

I just don't know enough about him, thats why am saying i think there is equally questions over him as everyone else.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top