Rank The Everton Goalkeepers

[Saint Domingo]

Pickford v Martyn is an interesting one. I always felt Martyn was perhaps positionally superior and knew his angles better etc.

Pickford has the better reactions, is better with his feet and raises his game for the bigger moments (relegation run ins, England games)

 

[NilSatisOptimum]

1. Southall
2. Pickford
3. Martyn
4. Howard

Can see why Martyn comes second for some he shone brightly, alas was very short compared to other 3.

 

[Blackwell Livermore]

1. Nev
2. Nige
3. Picks
4. Secretary of Defence aka jumper

I love all of them equally.

 

[NilSatisOptimum]

Simmonsen?

Sakes Myhre...

 

[Dutch Toffee]

Nev
JP
Martyn
Howard

Tough to separate 2 and 3. Both very good but Pickford has been here longer and arguably a very big part of the reason we havent gone down, so gets my vote.

I go with this. Although Big Nev is no 1 by quite some distance. Not really fair to compare the other 3 to him. He was an absolutely amazing goalkeeper. Probably the best one (or at the very least in the top 3), I've seen in my lifetime.

 

[Exeter_Gently]

Big Nev obviously first but if we look back at the saves Pickford has made in crucial games over the past 3 seasons,it's frightening.

I personally think he's only one in the squad we'll really struggle to replace.

 

[peteblue]

Southall
Pickford
Martyn
Howard.

We have been fortunate with our keepers……

 

[MisterJ]

Wasn't Pat Jennings on our books at one point?

 

[Jebus_lives]

Southall
JP
Martyn
Howard

Martyn shone very brightly for a brief moment. Had he been here longer he might be higher.

Pickford, has become more assured the longer he's been here.

 

[Papa Shango]

Wasn't Pat Jennings on our books at one point?

He was a reserve goalie in the 86 cup final.

 

[twoblue]

Nev
JP / martyn



Howard

 

[MisterJ]

Thought there was only one sub in those days and it was usually Harper or Richardson

 

[Blast_of_Cannock]

Simmonsen?

Only 1 m. He's in the photo someone posted earlier.

 

[Macker07]

1. Southall
2. Martyn
3. Howard
4. Pickford

I'm.with Lob

 

[heatmeiser]

I'm.with Lob

Howard above Pickford is wild