Rank The Everton Goalkeepers

[Gene Parmesan]

Howard is clearly bottom. Can’t believe anyone would choose him over Pickford.

I think the real question is between Pickford and Martyn. Martyn was more consistent because Pickford has had some bad periods but those were more in his earlier days. I’d say overall contribution to the club and longevity leans it more towards Pickford.

 

[Joey66]

Nigel Martyn will always be a ‘what could have been’ for us. Great for us at the tail end of his career but all the more mystifying that Peter Johnson and Joe Royle managed to let him slip through and go and spend his prime years at Leeds.
Is there any truth in the story that Johnson kept Martyn and his agent waiting at his hamper factory to discuss his transfer?

First time around he arrived to have talks - no one was there to greet him so he went to Leeds - Everton That ....