Rate the Window

[Leylo]

Trying to be positive .. 10 if Holgate goes to west brom

Didn't know it was west Brom ... unreal they already know he is grim

 

[nsno-chris]

A manager should be appointed that fits whatever the philosophy is.

I’m not sure what ours is tho or if we have one

In all honesty I have no idea what Thelwells philosophy is.

 

[matty1878]

Didn't know it was west Brom ... unreal they already know he is grim

 

[stamullenblue]

Didn't know it was west Brom ... unreal they already know he is grim

Hopefully they forgot !

 

[Ragnar]

Went with 7. We managed 2 keep DCL, Brainthwaite, and Pickford. Plus we brought inn a few new players that look exciting.

 

[BlueStevie35]

Didn't know it was west Brom ... unreal they already know he is grim

He was popular there wasn’t he? It’s Southampton and Sheff Utd who hated him

 

[Daytripper]

In all honesty I have no idea what Thelwells philosophy is.

Me neither. I looked into his time at Wolves and he seemed to have some detractors in their fan base, not a majority.

Seems a nice fella but I can’t say I’m too impressed. Bringing in players like Beto, McNeil etc .

If we get someone decent to takeover then maybe it’s time to part ways

 

[Nymzee]

6/10 for me.

Stronger CB depth.
Stronger in midfield.
More attacking flair.

Full-back's ignored again.
Striker situation ignored.
Pacey wide player ignored.

10/10

Holgate's gone.

 

[Lob]

I don't think it matters how good it was when they are being managed by one of the worst managers in the league. He would have city in a relegation battle this fella.

 

[nsno-chris]

Me neither. I looked into his time at Wolves and he seemed to have some detractors in their fan base, not a majority.

Seems a nice fella but I can’t say I’m too impressed. Bringing in players like Beto, McNeil etc .

If we get someone decent to takeover then maybe it’s time to part ways

I’m pretty sure a lot of them criticised his inability to add attacking threat.

 

[Frosty1878]

Here’s my take on it O’Brien is a Godfrey replacement maybe better but doesn’t improve the starting squad. Lindstrom is going to take time work in progress doesn’t improve the starting 11, Tim has looked good but young and will make some mistakes along the way, probably does improve the starting 11, ndiaye if he’s played instead of Doucoure will probably improve the starting 11. Pretty awful window could have done with a winger who can get at players with a bit of pace and a ST also a RB and maybe even a LB. Oh mangala decent squad player but don’t think he will do anything fantastic let’s hope I’m wrong and they all surprise us. But either way our manager is utter and we’re terrible to watch.

 

[TheBigIguana]

It’s basically an N/A for me because I have no idea what anyone is doing. Are we recruiting for Dyche? Recruiting for the guy we want when we get the chance to sack Dyche? Recruiting for the hell of it?

It’s just so hard to say, the only saving grace is we seem to not have thrown money away on older, proven to be bad players. So I guess it’s high marks on that.

 

[Tigger]

Underwhelming, gone for 5 but leaning more towards 4 than 6.

 

[Cally66]

Pretty good. 5/10 (pretty good relative to precious ones).
Shifted dead wood so old and lingering it was practically coal.
Got in some optimism.
Kept Branthwaite.

 

[Bazlar]

@Littlesue must be doing cartwheels at the Holgate news