Eggsyblueskin
Player Valuation: £40m
I originally voted 7 , but after the Broja bombshell I would reduce it to 2.
Osamabindiesel
Player Valuation: £60m
We brought in some good players in Obrien and Tim. Maybe Ndiaye too (and hopefully Jesper). But we addressed basically nothing in the team except for depth at CM and 10 if Dyche’s selections are anything to go by. 
Davideeyore
Player Valuation: £30m
This window is shattering.
Overall 7/10
JO'B for Holgate
Yes
Dixon for Godfrey. Weaker for now although I have a sneaking suspicion the RD's pace means he can be a good RW cover (DM did the same with a young Seamus). Young, JT and Coleman all a year older. We've kept Branthwaite. Defence marginally stronger. Hopefully Patterson can get fit and we get lucky with Mykolenkos fitness. We stayed up last year because we got really lucky injuries wise. We look more resilient this time.
MIDFIELD
Tim and Mangala for Onana and Gomes. About the same. But Tim looks like he is a proper CM that will get better and better. Onana was a Legend in his own head. Armstrong looks like he has really good potencial. Garner starting to be a season premier league player.
Slightly better.
Wide midfielders:
Lindstrom & Ndiaye for Dobbin & Danjuma
D&D contributed next to nothing last year.
Stronger
Attaclking mid
Ndiaye or Lindstrom for Doucoure. Stronger.
Striker:
DCL going to have to prove his worth if he wants the big move.
Borja has to prove himself. Will keep DCL on his toes
Beto has his second season in English football. Should improve.
Chermiti looked way better than last year in pre-season.
Stronger
We are miles away from where we want to be but this window was a step in the right dirección.
Foxes and Saints going down. Between us, Ipswich, Wolves, Cherries, Brentford and Forest for the last spot.
We should be fine.
JO'B for Holgate
Yes
Dixon for Godfrey. Weaker for now although I have a sneaking suspicion the RD's pace means he can be a good RW cover (DM did the same with a young Seamus). Young, JT and Coleman all a year older. We've kept Branthwaite. Defence marginally stronger. Hopefully Patterson can get fit and we get lucky with Mykolenkos fitness. We stayed up last year because we got really lucky injuries wise. We look more resilient this time.
MIDFIELD
Tim and Mangala for Onana and Gomes. About the same. But Tim looks like he is a proper CM that will get better and better. Onana was a Legend in his own head. Armstrong looks like he has really good potencial. Garner starting to be a season premier league player.
Slightly better.
Wide midfielders:
Lindstrom & Ndiaye for Dobbin & Danjuma
D&D contributed next to nothing last year.
Stronger
Attaclking mid
Ndiaye or Lindstrom for Doucoure. Stronger.
Striker:
DCL going to have to prove his worth if he wants the big move.
Borja has to prove himself. Will keep DCL on his toes
Beto has his second season in English football. Should improve.
Chermiti looked way better than last year in pre-season.
Stronger
We are miles away from where we want to be but this window was a step in the right dirección.
Foxes and Saints going down. Between us, Ipswich, Wolves, Cherries, Brentford and Forest for the last spot.
We should be fine.
Had very low expectations of the window at the start of the summer.
Think we’ve done some incredible work getting rid of dead wood and brought in the guts of £130 mill worth of footballers on two permanents for 25 mill and four loans.
Fair play.
Think we’ve done some incredible work getting rid of dead wood and brought in the guts of £130 mill worth of footballers on two permanents for 25 mill and four loans.
Fair play.
brieverton
Player Valuation: £40m
We're stronger on paper. Yes I know the game is played on grass.
I'd look at it two ways. We've got O'Brien, Iroegbunam, Lindstrom, Ndiaye, Mangala, and now Broja. Onana who never hit the heights out and JB retained. All of them should offer something though I think Broja will just be one of those punts where he gets 2 goals. We lose little if he fails.
DCL in all likelihood leaving on a free is the black mark, that's poor planning and poor management.
With talk of a fire sale before last season ended, they have made a little go a long way. The issue is how much time will these players get and the unaddressed issues of cover, pace, goals, and squad balance. Goals cost money we don't have. When you don't have it you take punts. You need luck and lots of it.
I think they've taken advantage of deals that came up as opportunities rather than necessarily trying to work through a list of targets in different positions. I can understand that to an extent. We are deal takers and not deal makers.
That probably makes for a lack of joined up thinking between Thelwell and Dyche. A disconnect between "here are the players I could get for you" versus any that would have been on a Dyche shortlist.
Overall though I think they have done well. It's simply not feasible to cover off every problem area for a club with our financial and PSR issues.
The question is does Dyche have the wherewithall and flexibility to take the players added and mould them into something better than the sum of their parts? Hmm.
I give them 6.5 / 10. That would have been a "C" when I was in school. I think we have enough to avoid relegation and do marginally better than last year without the deductions.
I'd look at it two ways. We've got O'Brien, Iroegbunam, Lindstrom, Ndiaye, Mangala, and now Broja. Onana who never hit the heights out and JB retained. All of them should offer something though I think Broja will just be one of those punts where he gets 2 goals. We lose little if he fails.
DCL in all likelihood leaving on a free is the black mark, that's poor planning and poor management.
With talk of a fire sale before last season ended, they have made a little go a long way. The issue is how much time will these players get and the unaddressed issues of cover, pace, goals, and squad balance. Goals cost money we don't have. When you don't have it you take punts. You need luck and lots of it.
I think they've taken advantage of deals that came up as opportunities rather than necessarily trying to work through a list of targets in different positions. I can understand that to an extent. We are deal takers and not deal makers.
That probably makes for a lack of joined up thinking between Thelwell and Dyche. A disconnect between "here are the players I could get for you" versus any that would have been on a Dyche shortlist.
Overall though I think they have done well. It's simply not feasible to cover off every problem area for a club with our financial and PSR issues.
The question is does Dyche have the wherewithall and flexibility to take the players added and mould them into something better than the sum of their parts? Hmm.
I give them 6.5 / 10. That would have been a "C" when I was in school. I think we have enough to avoid relegation and do marginally better than last year without the deductions.
GoldenToffee
Player Valuation: £60m
Consider the manager and director of football would have been told they're selling a big name and not getting to spend all the money generated, I think it's a great window.
Yet again absolutely disgraceful to still be suffering from years gone by, so much so that we're still in a position where we cannot spend even what's brought in, never mind anything on top of that, but that's how it is and hopefully we somehow have enough within the squad to stay up until a new owner can help up move forwards.
8/10.
Yet again absolutely disgraceful to still be suffering from years gone by, so much so that we're still in a position where we cannot spend even what's brought in, never mind anything on top of that, but that's how it is and hopefully we somehow have enough within the squad to stay up until a new owner can help up move forwards.
8/10.
carolinablue232
Player Valuation: £70m
Decent players brought in but we didn’t address our biggest weaknesses once again. I’d say 4, but Maupay is gone again so 5.
Acrobat
Player Valuation: £8m
This. My thoughts, and rating, exactly!
Walter Ego
Player Valuation: £30m
Broja is a strange signing. Looked promising on loan at Southampton a few years ago but couldn’t seem to score goals. He could have just been unlucky but since then has done exactly the same and is also now injury prone. The price tag therefore seems very high. And what does this do for the progression of Chermiti? Another strange signing for a club with no money. We have one left back and apparently only one right back who will be considered. The replacement for both is a 39 year old who is obviously well past it.
I’ve lost confidence in Thelwell. Dyche maybe the better the devil you know for the situation we’re in but I think after this season, hopefully there’ll be a new stadium, owner, DoF and manager.
I’ve lost confidence in Thelwell. Dyche maybe the better the devil you know for the situation we’re in but I think after this season, hopefully there’ll be a new stadium, owner, DoF and manager.