kenada_blue
Welcome to Barcelonaton FC
"Good football" is entirely subjective. Probably a very loose definition would be any style of football where you try an win a game by scoring a few goals from open play. How that manifests itself is entirely subjective. Barcelona's Tiki Taka was a very slow style of football but extraordinarily technical and effective. Bayerns Total football was all about getting the ball forward as quickly as possible and creating disruption in the transition. Most teams these days play the second style.
Trying to go 1-0 up off a set piece and sit on it is the very definition of bad football though and has never been anything else. Even the Simeones and Mourinhos of the world wouldn't go for it.
What we are seeing now at Everton is why. Eventually you will always revert to the mean and for every fluke worldie from Coleman to win you a game there will be 5 where it doesn't work out. Carlos season with us was a great example of this at Everton. Top of the league playing attacking football, fell down the league playing negative football.
And for what it is worth i don't agree with the last point. Over the last few years more clubs that have come up have stayed up, and it has been the ones who come up playing attacking football that tend to stick.
It's means to an end with what you have though isn't it?
We have an awful squad who can't score goals so what do you do to get goals and wins?
Carlo sussed that out and changed to a more pragmatic approach cos the quality wasn't there. He still got the max out of that squad.
You play attacking football successfully based on solid foundations. Roberto Martinez' Wigan played eye catching football the right way, won an FA Cup, now that club is languishing in league 1/champo. Blackpool, Leeds, Norwich, Huddersfield...just naming a few who played great attacking football at one point...all flopped based on foundations.
Last season Norwich, Brentford, Watford came up. Norwich and Watford went down. Season before...Leeds, West Brom, Fulham. West Brom and Fulham went down. Season before that Villa, Sheff United, Norwich...
Out of 3 that go up, most go down. Well...apart from this season.