The fan base has an obsession with managers. A lot still seem to believe we’re a few months of progressive coaching by Graeme Potter away from challenging for Europe.
The only manager I truly believe to be a complete dunce was Koeman. The rest have all been good enough managers (yes even Allardyce and Benitez) not to have us in a relegation scrap every other season. When we keep finding ourselves there however, there’s always something to blame, it’s the connection with the fan base that’s not there, the players don’t like him, he’s fallen out with Brands, his coaching is prehistoric etc.
6 managers in however many seasons all experiencing the same problems should be an absolute sure indicator that it’s not the manager.
Terrible player conditioning, injury prevention, and injury recovery
Awful recruitment, both selling buying and contract length leading to FFP issues
Terrible club structure and culture, ‘expected losses’, ‘you’ve had good times’, who actually makes decisions at Everton?
Trigger happy ownership changing the manager every time an angry fan demands it
A truly awful squad of players who are completely apathetic and cowardly (where was all this heroic effort at the end of Benitez/ start of Lampard?)
These are the bigger problems at the club, but large elements of the fan base have an obsession with manager and can’t get past it.