Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Roberto Martinez Discussion - Including Live Poll (Poll Reset 1st May)

Martinez in or out?

  • In

  • Out

  • Getting splinters eating cheese on toast on the fence


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
So it's Stubbs, rather than season after season of Moyes drilling them in defending, how to hold a shape, when to press, as Cahill described in his book.

Martinez inherited a very well drilled unit, and according to Cahill, Moyes would spend a lot of hours drilling them in defending.
3 of them are still there so why aren't they still doing it?
In my opinion it's because Martinez has coached it out of them but in his first season Stubbs was there to stop this happening so quickly.

If Stubbs wasn't there I reckon all our defensive woes would have started a lot earlier.
 
This is the crux of judging any football manager. Moyes won nothing, Walter Smith won nothing, Mike Walker won nothing and Roberto Martinez has won nothing. We can talk about football style and argue about 72 points but ultimately this is how history will judge him as Everton manager.
...yet.
 
Hes had the credit for his first season, almost everybody was onboard after that, but that was 18months ago David, since then we have seen a decline, a decline in results, a decline in performance, a decline in league placing.

We simply cant wait for this man to get a clue, if he ever will, hes been a manager for 7 years now, if the penny hasnt dropped yet it never will.

LOL
 
It's the lack of consistency that puzzles me. If people had said post Chelsea game: "that's it, he's got to go, had enough regardless" you could acknowledge that as something more than opportunism.
Dave, you first said no plotter came on the forum giving him credit, you had your eye wiped on that. Now it's no one came online typing he still has to go after a euphoric win. Anyone being negative instead of actually enjoying seeing the team win at home against a non-relegation threatened team would deserve a cyber-hiding.
 
Last edited:
Your opinion mate, and are entitled to it. Not for me though. It's a conclusion based on three seasons when we got a PL points record; followed by two seasons where we've slipped back to midtable but in this one have been very competitive all season and in the cups in particular.

How any Evertonian is concluding from that mixed bag that a manager isn't working out beggars belief.

Because that 'mixed bag' is nothing of the sort. It might be a mixed bag if we were currently 6-10th this season but we're not, and unlikely to be.

It's regression.
 

I love the take on Martinez's career: 72 points = Moyes was responsible; FA Cup win = he killed a football club to do it. Have you ever thought your argument would benefit from giving the man some well earned credit? Just a thought.

As for Moyes' time here: who is arguing that Martinez should have an indefinite period set aside for him? I've argued he has a contract for 5 seasons and should be allowed to get on with it. No more than that. Back him and leave the man to get on with it. The only way that should be called time on early is if we were in imminent danger. As it is we're not and we're in a decent position to snatch a trophy. And who apart from a a few panickers thought we'd be relegated last season? It's an absurd claim.

Of course we stayed at the same level: he was an experienced manager with a squad that knew the ropes in the PL from previous campaigns and he sacrificed only Rodwell and Arteta of any note to make up the cost cutting. Why would there be a big drop off?

And, btw, this was at a time when competition from below was not what it is today as a result of all teams being massively bankrolled now.

I'm not arsed about 7 seasons. He hasn't been here at Everton 7 seasons. You may as well put Swansea's figures in too, it's about as relevant.

Of course they're not as consistent or as accomplished as the 80s Everton team. That wasn't the claim though was it? He's attempted to take us in a different direction to the muck served up previously masquerading as football and Everton have been complimented on their style hundreds of times this season for playing expansive football and scoring more goals from open play than any other club. Is your assessment of this manager that warped by bias that you cant eevn acknowledge what the vast majority of football fans would concede?

I don't give him any credit, you don't give him any blame mate, i however do give him credit for the first season, but i also am not so blind to not relaise that he did benefit from the previous manager, did he take it on a level ofc he did, but after the defensive rigidty he inheritted faded we can evaluate him more clearly - this is now a Martinez team in all its 'glory'

give him the neght of his contract unless we are in imminent danger of relegation - jesus mate this is a results business, so we should be the only club in football that doesn't expect it's manager to perform at a sufficient level and should just nod like a dog in the back seat no matter what, this is showing you up as somene with bad double standards - what you are advocating is exactly what you slated the board for over many years - for acceptance of mediocrity and just being happy with the statis quo

The Everton manager accepts supporters’ frustration is understandable after eight matches without a win and, having previously insisted the club’s ambitions should remain to qualify for Europe, concedes the team is immersed in a fight for survival.
“I’ve been long enough in this league to understand how difficult it is to get to 40 points. In the same way, I know what we are capable of doing. Last season showed our standard and that is what we are fighting for. We know what level we can reach.

Thats from january last year

Everton manager Roberto Martinez has accepted that the club are in a relegation battle. Martinez's side are six points above the relegation zone after winning one of their last 12 Premier League games. Everton have 28 points from 28 games, their lowest total at this stage of a season in the Premier League era. "Any team that hasn't got 40 points in the final third of the season is in a relegation fight," Martinez told the Sunday Telegraph. "The big advantage I have is that I've been through that every season." Martinez won successive relegation battles as manager with Wigan Athletic in 2010, 2011 and 2012 before they went down in 2013, days after winning the FA Cup. "Yes, yes, but I've been down with 36 points and it's very tough to get 36 points in this league," Martinez said. "It was very painful because it was on the back of winning the FA Cup. The FA Cup final got in the middle of achieving that and we paid the price."

thats from march the same year

So apparently Martinez was one of the panickers as he admitted twice that we where in a relation battle mate - and in March we mst certainly where

Moyes also sold Lescott mate, but you omitted that one ofc

Your not arsed about the 7 seasons then so dont want to include the time at Wigan, ok lets scrap that fa cup win from him then too mate - be ncie now remember your not able to refer to that or else your being naughty

As for the entertainers - yeah lots of neutral fans who see us once in a blue moon or highlights on match of the day now and again may think we are brilliant to watch - the fans who go the game though are fed up of the way we play, no tempo - no bite, but hey we get compliments from Michael Owen and some fat muppet journo for the mail so we must be boss, ofc ingore all the negative comments about the style we play and how it is tactically naive etc, because that doesn't suit what you want to here
 
And what are Everton under Martinez?! The Barcelona Z team?

You're acting like Leicester are a dirty team ffs. I disagree, and think you are 100% being snobbish.
We okay and succeed in playing open and attacking football most of the time, as the club that has most open play goals that is a fact.

Be my guest, enjoy the footy served up by Leicester. Me? It's helter skelter, kick and rush stuff and leaves me cold.
 
3 of them are still there so why aren't they still doing it?
In my opinion it's because Martinez has coached it out of them but in his first season Stubbs was there to stop this happening so quickly.

If Stubbs wasn't there I reckon all our defensive woes would have started a lot earlier.
I don't think defenders have forgot how to defend, I just think Martinez style and way we play at home leaves us with holes and exposed, the fullbacks bomb on too far too quickly, leaving us exposed if we lose the ball, we don't tend to do this as much away hence the better results.

Too gung ho at home is our problem.
 

I just see all this as a fever mate. Where were these bold unavoidable conclusions after the Chelsea game? Where was your statement to that effect then ? Nowhere to be seen. So, why after a loss to Arsenal do you arrive at the conclusion now?

Cos I am not one to base an opinion on one game. Or run around with my hair on fire. And, FWIW, I didnt actually see the Arsenal game, just listened to it, plus MOTD.

In terms of setting him targets that other managers havnt been set, I am saying that the balance of evidence over 3 years here, (didnt notice Wigan really), his achillies heel is undoing the great stuff he does. On the pitch and off it. So fix it. Permanently. But he doesnt. Time and time again.

I would love him to bolt together a terrific last phase of the season, and win the cup. Because he has proved he can. But he has also proved his stubborn attitude, (which can be a strength), has contributed to a hopeless home record, and a (probable) pitiful league position for the squad he has assembled.

Patience is pretty thin with me, to say the least.
 
You may not like the way Leicester play but I bet you won't find a Leicester fan saying 'I know we might be top but I really wish we could swap managers with Everton because I much prefer the football they play.'
I dont care what those people think. They're not even arsed about footy really. Rugby is their game..and the footy team plays a variation of it.
 
We okay and succeed in playing open and attacking football most of the time, as the club that has most open play goals that is a fact.

Be my guest, enjoy the footy served up by Leicester. Me? It's helter skelter, kick and rush stuff and leaves me cold.

But it WORKS doesn't it?

My hat's off to Ranieri; he's come into a load of journeymen and average players, played them to a style that loads of managers haven't been able to better, or even suss out.

Martinez, though....Who isn't wise to his one-track football?

Of course you've got both of them well sussed - haven't you?
 
1407569542-mural2.jpg


I still think this was to blame for it all...
That was when all those currently attacking him and demanding his head were calling him Bobby Brown Shoes.

*YOU know who you are*
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top