Yes, he was that great.
He wasn't consistent nor did he play all that often for us....but by Jove when he was on a going day he was the amalgam of the player every one of us ever dreamed of having at our club.
The way he ran at the RS when he came on as sub....the dart into the Old Trafford penalty box which instigated the move for Oviedo's goal...the sparkling display and superb goal against Stoke....and of course the highlight of his time with EFC, the sublimity of the goal at Arsenal.
Alas, it was all over for Gerald and Everton by the middle of December as he never shone so brightly after his injury, but he did make a very telling contribution for Ross's wonder goal at the Barcodes. He won the ball on the edge of our box to send Wavertree's finest on his way.
He lit up that golden period we had around this time last year, when between the Goodison derby and Ossie's back pass on Boxing Day we were playing the best football in the country.
I think one of the reasons we are all so down at the moment despite the team not doing all that badly in the league and Europe having proven to be a happy hunting ground thus far is that we know what might have been if he was still around.
And FWIW there is no doubt in my mind we would have gone on to claim a CL spot last season happen Gerald hadn't sustained that injury against Fulham.
Tbf I had completely forgotten about how much of a torrid time he gave the RS in the derby, ignoring the fact he missed a couple of big chances he was absolutely tearing them a new one. Still trying to erase the final score of that game out of my memory is probably the reason for the forgetfulness!