Very good is a stretch.But... He was genuinely very good once upon a time. He was deservedly England #1.
He's turd now and I agree with you that he's done but let's not rewrite history and pretend he was always quite this bad.
And there's another thing we need to be honest about too - we never as a fan base wanted to forgive him for Origi. So even when he's had spells since where he's been just OK, we've still hated him and were waiting for the next mistake to have a pop.
And he just kept providing mistake after mistake.
Made less mistakes yes, but don't think he's ever been very good.