Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Ronald Koeman discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
Was Moyes responsible for us finishing 5th?

No.

Martinez took players and moulded them into something better. Simple answer.

Delusion. Can you explain what happen in his 2nd and 3rd season? 22 wins in 75 league games which caused him the sack, deservedly.
 
There are players who were engraved with the Moyes way, tight solid shape, those players then had to try and adapt to Martinez and his possession is everything, defending is nothing approach. These players partially adapted to this in the first season and caught a lot of people by surprise but in time the inevitable happened and Martinez destroyed the defensive mentality and work rate that Moyes put into them. Martinez got in players to suit his 'way' who evidently can't defend and actually couldn't pass keep the ball and the Martinez way was found out big time.

Koeman brought in a couple of players in the summer, one of whom is or should I say was the mould of what he wants, especially the attacking part of the pitch in Bolasie. He obviously wanted more than had been brought in, just look at how ruthless he was with Niasse after just 20 minutes in Austria.

We all know how many players the squad needs binning, regardless of the result we have the same players underperforming consistently.
 

@mkrudden all I'm saying is that you called a poster 'Crazy' for blaming Martinez for Everton's current predicament, that's fine it's your opinion. But for the purposes of consistency, that would mean you then think Moyes had no influence on 13/14.

Again that's fine, if that's your opinion.

But I strongly disagree.

That's exactly why, contrary to what you just said, I'm being 100% consistent (you've still not explained that dig) by crediting, in part, the manager of the previous season for the current one. I did it with Moyes/Martinez and now I'm doing it with Martinez/Koeman.

Not inconsistent at all.
 

Ok, that's fine, so you see no inconsistency in Martinez defensive record from his 8 seasons as a PL manager and which one stood out?

Moyes was a great manager for us. Agreed. But he had stagnated, surely you agree with that? Martinez was a breath of fresh air. He ultimately failed.
I'm not trying to glorify Martinez or degrade Moyes. I'm saying that Koemans immunity from this all is ridiculous.

Let me ask you this:

If Moshiri hadn't come in and there was no way of buying our way out of this, would you be satisfied?
 
Stop talking about gash and gasher please and back our new manager as he tries to sort out this mess.
You can back a manager and hope he sorts things out whilst still expressing reservations about the progress, or lack of it, you are seeing.

We seem slightly better in our defensive organisation but the number of chances we create, specially in the first half of games, is pretty dire. Also don't think any of the players have noticeabley improved over the past few weeks - you'd expect a good coach to at least be able to get his concepts across to one or two even as he awaits his own recruits.
 
Moyes was a great manager for us. Agreed. But he had stagnated, surely you agree with that? Martinez was a breath of fresh air. He ultimately failed.
I'm not trying to glorify Martinez or degrade Moyes. I'm saying that Koemans immunity from this all is ridiculous.

Let me ask you this:

If Moshiri hadn't come in and there was no way of buying our way out of this, would you be satisfied?
Even more so with the squad and it's character/mentality he was left.

Moyes left a team, Martinez left a squad.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top