2023/24 Seamus Coleman

[PhoenixIreland]

Hes the prime example of why this club has to sell players at their peak before their downturn.

If we had sold him and used all of the money to reinvest in a young high potential player to start + another to develop we would not be forced to watch him on the pitch.

Nor read about how hes a "top bloke" etc etc

No one wanted to buy him and they were right.

 

[MikeH72]

Bedwetting gimps. Yeah it's all Seamus Colemans fault.

Leave the Coleman thread if you don’t want to see Coleman’s performances evaluated.

 

[Jimmy Grimble]

Nonsense about him stealing a wage. I'm pretty sure he doesn't need the money.
Her didn't beg for a new contract- quite the opposite- the club asked him to sign. He thought long and hard about it. In his case, I am pretty sure he did so to try to help the club that he loves. 60 grand, was an excellent right back and will always be one of my favourites. Of course we should be moving on to younger and better, but it's not his fault that we haven't managed to do that.

 

[Moomin]

We do need to sign a new right back.

Use the funds from the Godfrey and Patterson sale to invest in new blood.

 

[GH_1982]

Hes the prime example of why this club has to sell players at their peak before their downturn.

If we had sold him and used all of the money to reinvest in a young high potential player to start + another to develop we would not be forced to watch him on the pitch.

Nor read about how hes a "top bloke" etc etc

On that basis we should have sold pickford to united/spurs over the last few years and branthwaite should be sold this summer?

We have invested in Patterson but dyche won't pick him for some reason.

Your theory would be great if we could reinvest smartly but we change the manager too frequently.


Dyche doesn't strike me a development manager

 

[blueblood]

He should be cover from the bench, not starting at right back with a 39 year old playing in front of him.

 

[Nymzee]

If he loved Everton he’d have given up on Ireland for us.

 

[Drico]

If he loved Ireland, he’d have given up on Everton for us.

 

[DualityNSNO]

He should be cover from the bench, not starting at right back with a 39 year old playing in front of him.

But then how will we get ExPeRiEnCe?

 

[Daveysgingerlovechild]

He was pretty bad last night. Getting close to the Phil Neville Wigan moment. When realisation the legs have gone kicks in.

 

[Frosty1878]

Hes the prime example of why this club has to sell players at their peak before their downturn.

If we had sold him and used all of the money to reinvest in a young high potential player to start + another to develop we would not be forced to watch him on the pitch.

Nor read about how hes a "top bloke" etc etc

No he’s not Deli alli, tosun, Beto and even your man Onana are a prime example of what not to buy players who don’t give a about the club and have bled us dry with little to no return on what we’ve paid or performances. We should of replaced Coleman years ago we kind of did with Patterson and that hasn’t worked out we’re skint and can’t do anything else other than use the crap we have not really Coleman’s fault or even Dyche’s that’s on the board and useless directors of football we’ve had.

 

[Charlie Sweet]

Leave the Coleman thread if you don’t want to see Coleman’s performances evaluated.

Hypocrite what? Look at your comments in the Patterson thread calling out anyone that criticises.

Coleman was bad last night - but they all were.

 

[Joey66]

Hypocrite what? Look at your comments in the Patterson thread calling out anyone that criticises.

Coleman was bad last night - but they all were.

Yes he was bad & Young - but they are sadly finished = hang their boots up & let's see some youth players ....

 

[MikeH72]

Hypocrite what? Look at your comments in the Patterson thread calling out anyone that criticises.

Coleman was bad last night - but they all were.

Patterson hasn’t been playing and has still been getting slated, that’s the key difference.

 

[DanEFC92]

Good idea putting him up against some of the fastest wingers in the league.