Seamus Coleman

DanEFC92 · September 24, 2016

Bring back Holgate.

summerisle · September 27, 2016

As a small antidote to football greed.

granter79 · September 30, 2016

One of the only positives tonight. Glimpses of the old coleman n loomed only player that was going to score.

dan78 · September 30, 2016

Dithered to much tonight not enough composure

scottym · September 30, 2016

Thought he was poor tonight. Took an extra 5 seconds over every decision, floated crosse which needed whipping in and that diving header out of play when he could have brought the ball down in the box was just bizarre.

ToffeeTim · September 30, 2016

One of the worst performances I've seen from him

Papa Shango · September 30, 2016

granter79 said:
One of the only positives tonight. Glimpses of the old coleman n loomed only player that was going to score.

Funny how differently people see the same game.

I thought he was poor. His positioning and attempt at challenging for Benteke's goal was shocking.

Paul w · September 30, 2016

granter79 said:
One of the only positives tonight. Glimpses of the old coleman n loomed only player that was going to score.

Really though he was piss poor.

suey_11 · September 30, 2016

He was poor but kept bombing forward needs to be more instinctive as soon as he pauses, he's not skillfull enough to beat a player or pick out a killer pass.

deipnosophist · September 30, 2016

He has his moments, but overall Evertonians over-rate him

LouReedwalkonthewildside · September 30, 2016

Thought after Holgate playing so well, he was unlucky to be dropped, and Coleman walking right back into the side.

Joey66 · September 30, 2016

LouReedwalkonthewildside said:
Thought after Holgate playing so well, he was unlucky to be dropped, and Coleman walking right back into the side.

Could Holgate not play at left back? fast and versatile????

LouReedwalkonthewildside · September 30, 2016

Joey66 said:
Could Holgate not play at left back? fast and versatile????

Don't see why not mate, suppose the argument against is why gamble playing a right footer on the left when we have a natural left footed player in Oviedo.

WycombeToffee · September 30, 2016

I thought he was our best player tonight (after Gueye). Strange how people see things so differently.

Joey66 · September 30, 2016

LouReedwalkonthewildside said:
Don't see why not mate, suppose the argument against is why gamble playing a right footer on the left when we have a natural left footed player in Oviedo.

who started off well and faded away in the 2nd half got subbed - he was poor at Bournemouth -he had a great first half helped by cleverly, but that meant tonight we had no width other than Coleman!