2023/24 Sean Dyche

[John BCN]

 

[Victus]

That arm is not by his side, unless you lot have funny gammy fcking arms.

 

[ToffeeTim]

Neither are penalties. Again: we should encourage more of these not being given not the other way round.

I agree they shouldn’t be penalties

But we were all told at the time that it was a clear penalty when City got that one.

So why the total lack of consistency?

If Onanas was a correct decision then this is a 100% certain penalty for handball.

 

[Shibbywiggles]

But that’s kinda the point isn’t it? We shouldn’t encourage MORE incorrect penalties just because it would benefit us. It wasn’t a pen and neither was Onana’s the other week.

But we were told during Onana’s replay that ‘it’s a pen in todays game’ and I would argue this was more of a pen than that one that was a yard out on a point blank powerful shot

I’d like them to both not be penalties for the good of the game but we were all told Onana gave away a pen so surely there should be consistency

 

[Nymzee]

I agree they shouldn’t be penalties

But we were all told at the time that it was a clear penalty when City got that one.

So why the total lack of consistency?

I mean consistency is a whole different story. Just saying for me, not a pen, no matter what soft ones have come before it.

 

[Shibbywiggles]

I agree they shouldn’t be penalties

But we were all told at the time that it was a clear penalty when City got that one.

So why the total lack of consistency?

If Onanas was a correct decision then this is a 100% certain penalty for handball.

Well you got there first but much like they’re both the same thing and both pens, we both said the same things and are both right

 

[maccavennie]

That arm is not by his side, unless you lot have funny gammy fcking arms.

I like to walk with a spring in my step and that's my arm position

 

[ToffeeTim]

I mean consistency is a whole different story. Just saying for me, not a pen, no matter what soft ones have come before it.

Consistency is what matters most and it matters more than my subjective opinion on what should or should not be given as a penalty. I'd personally rather have barely any of these handball penalties but we've been penalised with them so its only right we expect to get a decision like tonight.

The lack of Consistency this season has made the league look ridiculous. The fact we still haven't had 1 penalty is a complete joke.

 

[Nymzee]

Consistency is what matters most and it matters more than my subjective opinion on what should or should not be given as a penalty. I'd personally rather have barely any of these handball penalties but we've been penalised with them so its only right we expect to get a decision like tonight.

The lack of Consistency this season has made the league look ridiculous. The fact we still haven't had 1 penalty is a complete joke.

We’ve gone beyond the Dyche in the Dyche thread now so we’ll just leave it at a differing opinion.

 

[banno]

View attachment 244192

I know it is said in jest but it is true. Watched the match and that Tony Gayle the co-commentator (ex Fulham) was so biased in decisions, agreed is was handball (pen) but nothing he could do about it therefore not a pen. Consistency is something VAR does not understand. Arm was well outside his body?? as in Pic Thought that was a pen

 

[Richard Alex]

Robinson off the bar? Wasn't handball for me.

The law is an ass. I agree it’s harsh as it’s accidental. Just like Michael Keane at Anfield and Onana against City.
If you go to the rules of handball it should be a penalty.
In both of the instances against us the commentators agreed it’s harsh but they are given.
Robinson’s arm is out and the ball hits his hand. Pen.

 

[Mrbluenose]

The club really should be making more of a stink about this inconsistency.

Put pressure on the officials to either give us some or stop giving then against us.

 

[Toffe3m4n]

He's gonna need to find some goals in these players pronto.

 

[Frenk]

Fulham?

Nah mate.

 

[Eggs]

….he’s giving us a chance, very few managers in the game would achieve this. Doing a terrific job, we need to keep hold of him regardless of what happens.