We have a new manager and a new DOF. If they were to come straight into the club and jib players off without actually looking at them (yes even Mirallas and Williams) then I would sack them immediately as they would not be doing their job. With a possible exception or two nobody in the squad is inherently a bad player and they all have attributes that a manager may like or not. Silva may come in and think "That Besic is two footed, can tackle, can pass, has energy, I can do something with him." Conversely he may have a look at, I dunno, Baines lets say and think "That Baines is finished, his legs have gone and he cant defend, I can do better".
Until a manager spends a bit of time with a squad all kinds of things could happen so anyone assuming who is going or staying etc is just guessing based off past events under a totally different regime.
Yeah I get all that and I agree with it to a point, but let’s take Mirallas for example - overstayed his welcome here by about 4 years, continually disrespected the club, he’s not good at football and generally been a ball bag. How many chances does he deserve?? He’s utter garbage and a bad apple, should have been told to do one instantly. My point is - I would have thought since silva is a professional football manager and been our manager since before Christmas the homework would have done by now, it can’t be that hard in 5-6 months to identify the people they want and don’t want. I don’t buy the line that silva needs to see them to make a decision, there is clearly players here that don’t belong and should have been told instantly to stay at finch farm work on their fitness and find a new club. What if these ball bags that know they are getting punted start causing unrest whilst away.