Exactly how I feel, great when sung by thousands, absolute garbage when Kenwright insists they dust off Cyrils 78s and wind up the gramaphone.I don't mind when fans sing GOT/Everton forever...but when they are played on the tannoy pre match I find it toe curling embarrassing because the tunes sounds so old fashioned, like some 50's musical hall stuff. Not a fan of Spirit of the Blues either , sorry, it reminds me a bit of some early Saturday night light entertainment show would have as a tune.
Fan songs need to be catchy, not too complicated. The beard stroking musos online scoff at anything that isn't worthy of an Ivor Novello gong.
They're footy songs, sung by (mainly) man-baby knobheads.
They're all fine in that format. Even the Wooooo one.