Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Participation within this subforum is only available to members who have had 5+ posts approved elsewhere.

The small world of Eddie Howe

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's always difficult to tell how anyone will do elsewhere, but personally I just don't think Howe has done anything to suggest he would be a good appointment for us.

He did a great job getting Bournemouth up and keeping them there that first season, but since then they've barely treaded water. If he'd taken them even as high as 7th I'd maybe think he had a bit more about him, but bottom half finishes just don't impress me really, and they have a nasty habit of getting absolutely thrashed quite regularly which sets alarm bells going for me. He's clearly not a bad manager, but there's not a lot to suggest he's a particularly good one either. It would appear quite a lot of PL chairmen agree, based on the lack of offers he's had from elsewhere.
 
It's always difficult to tell how anyone will do elsewhere, but personally I just don't think Howe has done anything to suggest he would be a good appointment for us.

He did a great job getting Bournemouth up and keeping them there that first season, but since then they've barely treaded water. If he'd taken them even as high as 7th I'd maybe think he had a bit more about him, but bottom half finishes just don't impress me really, and they have a nasty habit of getting absolutely thrashed quite regularly which sets alarm bells going for me. He's clearly not a bad manager, but there's not a lot to suggest he's a particularly good one either. It would appear quite a lot of PL chairmen agree, based on the lack of offers he's had from elsewhere.

To each their own, I just can't think of another manager who has done what Howe has done. It's not just an OK job, it's a stupendous job.

His remit at Bournemouth has always been to buy young players at low cost and increase their potential resale value, while keeping them in the league, which he's done without much fuss. The Bournemouth board aren't going to set their expectations to qualify for Europe, their squad is tiny and it would kill them. It's been proven by many teams in the past that you have to be ready to qualify for Europe, the extra games take their toll.

For me, It's admirable to stick to your philosophy in the face of several losses of form which, by the way, he's always been able to dig Bournemouth out of. That takes resilience and a strong mentality. Also, alot of people have this impression of Howe as a soft touch, managing young players is often harder than managing senior pro's and they totally buy into him down there.

Again, watch the Harry Wilson goal v Newcastle earlier this season. Best set piece goal i've seen in years, proper innovative training ground drill, the likes of which we've never even attempted here in years!

People have been impressed by Wilder after just 14 games, and rightly so as he's done a great job at Sheffield United, but everything you could say about Wilder is even more true with Howe.

Some fans have very short memories, I get the feeling that he'll probably have to do well in the cup one year to get the recognition he deserves at fan level.

I don't think it's a case of a lack of offers for elsewhere, it's probably more likely the case that the offers he's had haven't been the right ones. It would take a bold board from the top six to appoint a manager from down the league and I'm not sure he'd consider a job with a team outside the top six unless they had genuine ambitions - otherwise it's just a sideward step.

He's an outside candidate for the Arsenal job. Alternatively, f Rodgers leaves for Arsenal, I'd say he's a shoe in for the Leicester job. When Mourinho leaves Spurs, I think he'd be a great candidate there too. And failing all that, I think he'll walk into the England job after Southgate.

Perfect for us in many ways.
 

Fraser (£400k) King (£3m), Wilson (£3m) Brooks (£11m) and Cook (£6m) for under £25m is pretty good too like.

Especially when you consider you'd have to pay easily £150m to get them now.
Bournemouth's owners are the second "poorest" in the PL after Burnley's

PS-Meant to reply to the post about the Russian oligarch quip.
 

Talksport are going to link him to Everton any second now as I listen

No time for anyone who listens to that guff. It’s worse than 5Live. Loads of ex-pro’s unconvincingly portraying unneccessarily extreme or controversial opinions to prompt ring-ins - usually showcasing the absolute worst mutants of each clubs’ respective fan base.
 
To each their own, I just can't think of another manager who has done what Howe has done. It's not just an OK job, it's a stupendous job.

Paul Jewell did the same job, but he did it for much, much less money.

In June 2001, Jewell made his return to management with ambitious Division Two club Wigan Athletic. In his second season as manager (2002–03) the club won the Division Two championship and entered the upper half of the English professional football league system for the first time ever. They were near the top of Division One throughout the 2003–04 season but were pipped to a playoff place on the final day of the season by Crystal Palace—who went on to win the playoffs.

On the final day of the 2004–05 Championship season, Jewell's Athletic side clinched promotion to the Premiership bringing top-flight football to the Lancashire town for the first time. For the 2005–06 season, Jewell's side lost their first game at home to Chelsea via a last-minute winner from Hernán Crespo but won their first match two games later at home to Sunderland. They contested the League Cup final against Manchester United on 26 February 2006 but went down 4–0.

On 11 February 2007 during the aftermath of Wigan's defeat at the hands of Arsenal, Jewell accused referee Phil Dowd of failing to award Wigan a penalty and for allowing what appeared to be an offside goal. After the game Jewell was charged by the FA for improper conduct regarding his verbally insulting the referee. For this offence Jewell was fined £2,000 and given a two match touchline ban (suspended for 12 months). A second charge relating to the same referee was brought by the Football Association, and was heard on 16 May 2007 and was found not proven.[7][8][9]

On the final day of the 2006–07 season, Jewell steered Wigan safe from relegation after a win against Sheffield United at Bramall Lane on 13 May 2007. A day later, Jewell resigned as Wigan manager due to health reasons.[10][11]
 
How much for them 5 mate? Modern market, bearing in mind that:

Ryan Fraser contributed as many goals and assists last season as Harry Kane and Lacazette (21)

Callum Wilson contributed as many goals and assists as Sadio Mane, more than Vardy (23)

Chelsea were widely reported to have been quoted £75m for Wilson in the summer. Even if you don't think he's worth that, you'd do well to get him for less than £60m.
The conundrum with most managers you employ is that there is no guarantee they can transfer moderate success at a smaller club to the greater ambitions of a bigger club.
Sometimes you win (Kendall and Royle) sometimes you lose (Martinez and Silva).
Maybe having played for a bigger club gives you a better understanding of the demands.

I think the biggest problem with the appointment of Eddie Howe is that it will cost millions to get him to Everton and millions to sack him if the need arises as we are in a weak bargaining position if he were to be our first choice.
We have probably been burned that way too often recently for it to happen again.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top