Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

The summer 2013 Everton transfer rumourZ thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
ijjysmith said:
Where have I had a pop?
Click to expand...

I gave my considered opinion on Redmond & you chose to reply with a sarcastic comment saying I obviously hadn't seen much of him, which I took (rightly) as a patronising pop. As I've seen plenty of him & I think he's nothing special.
 
Foot Long Hot Dog said:
I gave my considered opinion on Redmond & you chose to reply with a sarcastic comment saying I obviously hadn't seen much of him, which I took (rightly) as a patronising pop. As I've seen plenty of him & I think he's nothing special.
Click to expand...

Ok well that's not really a pop is it?

But anyway, can you tell me when you've seen him because I've seen a fair bit of him and like him a lot.
 
The problem with on here, took much lads judge players by their attributes on Fifa and FM. Everyone bumming Redmond, honestly, how much times have you seen him play. I seen Juan Carlos Menseguez play two games for WBA when on loan a couple of years back and he looked brilliant, soon looked up on him and they said he was utter garbage for the other 10 or so games and canceled his loan.

Redmond has never once excited me when I've seen him play, in his defense, that has only been about 3-4 times. 'Oh but his speed lad, his pace could tear defences apart down the wing' could he do that in PL? I have my doubts. He is only 19, but to only score two goals out the wing and from what I hear, playing as second striker for parts of the season is quite poor. I suppose we can't really judge him on his Euro Championships either, just as well, cause he was dirt at them, no idea how Sky thought he played "very well" against Italy.. never had the ball.
 
LocalNative said:
The problem with on here, took much lads judge players by their attributes on Fifa and FM. Everyone bumming Redmond, honestly, how much times have you seen him play. I seen Juan Carlos Menseguez play two games for WBA when on loan a couple of years back and he looked brilliant, soon looked up on him and they said he was utter garbage for the other 10 or so games and canceled his loan.

Redmond has never once excited me when I've seen him play, in his defense, that has only been about 3-4 times. 'Oh but his speed lad, his pace could tear defences apart down the wing' could he do that in PL? I have my doubts. He is only 19, but to only score two goals out the wing and from what I hear, playing as second striker for parts of the season is quite poor.
Click to expand...

See. This is a much better post.
 

ijjysmith said:
Ok well that's not really a pop is it?

But anyway, can you tell me when you've seen him because I've seen a fair bit of him and like him a lot.
Click to expand...

lol, so now you want a list of the fixtures so you can vet my level of knowledge?

I watched him a number of times when Brum were on the box, I also saw him live when they played at Leeds last season.

Is that Ok like?
 
Southall1EFC said:
So Phenom mate, do you watch players or something like that? I think we've all grasped that's how you make judgments on ability, but that's not to say it's the only measure of a player. It's quite off putting that your first inquest to any mention of a player is "How much have you watched of him" "I've been watching Scott Sinclair since he was 3 lid so you know fook all about him".

My point is that in this age there are streams available for just about every game if you want to find them. So yes I've watched Fer boss about a midfield and show an eye for goal from that position that we severely lack. Yes I've seen Bony absolutely slot chance after chance and show an inherent ability to turn half chance into a goal. I've even seen Redmond show tactical awareness beyond his age and maintain a consistent role for Birmingham to complement his pace.

Essentially, you sound like a douche at times and I'm not even sure you realize it. Take a moment to appreciate someone else's perspective. I'm sure you're proud that you've put in the effort to research theses players and scout their abilities but that doesn't diminish the validity of other poster's opinions.

Up the Toffees and all that
Click to expand...

Have you not read anything I've said, Ive openly admitted I havent watched a lot of these players, Chadli and Bony both of whom are in that Category, I have watched Fer since he was linked and looks a good prospect and Scott Sinclair is Turbo Gash.

If you give an opinion on how we should sign a player, I expect at the least you have seen this lad play 1 match, most on here have thats why I brought up Dutch because he has seen these players and I respect his opinion on them. A lot on here post also say lets buy A,B and C based on nothing bar a jarg link and a few youtube video's, its even been admitted if you actually read the posts.

Although you may want to back up the youtubers,CM and fifa generation theres plenty who dont mate.
 

Foot Long Hot Dog said:
lol, so now you want a list of the fixtures so you can vet my level of knowledge?

I watched him a number of times when Brum were on the box, I also saw him live when they played at Leeds last season.

Is that Ok like?
Click to expand...

Yes mate.

All I wanted was a reason or a few why you didnt like him. Makes your opinion more valid and I might learn something I didnt know.

See the other chaps post above.
 
When are the club going to get rid of heitinga . If some of these rumours are true about Martinez getting some South American cheap players then I believe Fellaini will be staying victor Moses on loan would be a deal I would like to push on for . We could then play a 4-3-3 with pace on both wings and Pienaar then could move central
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Register
Back
Top