The summer 2013 Everton transfer rumourZ thread

[ijjysmith]

The mirror states today where after MCarthy for £15m

The Mirror though. Use your loaf.

 

[hktoffee]

McCarthy is a very good player! Dont assume just because he plays for Wigan he is crap, he really isnt.

No, he is crap.

 

[flibbyflob]

The Mirror though. Use your loaf.

Wouldn't be surprised if we try, same article also says Kone for £6.5m and Alcatraz on a free.

 

[stinger]

Wenger has said Vermaelen can go for around £5 million. Well worth it in my opinion.

His reading of the game is awful for CB, but with Jagielka it wouldn't be so exposed. And he would be actually a decent replacement for Distin. Plus he can play as LCB in 3-man defense .

 

[Papa Shango]

No, he is crap.

No, hes not.... we could go on for ages im sure.

Hes not a 15M player dont get me wrong. But the people who are saying he is crap im sure they have been watching a different player.

 

[stinger]

I would love us to get Diame, thanks to clause in his contract he is probably cheaper than McCarthy and he's quality for me and would be perfect to play alongside Gibson. But his wages expectations are quite extreme...

 

[tim cahill]

His reading of the game is awful for CB, but with Jagielka it wouldn't be so exposed. And he would be actually a decent replacement for Distin. Plus he can play as LCB in 3-man defense .

You forgot to mention that he's Belgian.

 

[tim cahill]

I would love us to get Diame, thanks to clause in his contract he is probably cheaper than McCarthy and he's quality for me and would be perfect to play alongside Gibson. But his wages expectations are quite extreme...

What are his wages now?

 

[Phenom]

No, hes not.... we could go on for ages im sure.

Hes not a 15M player dont get me wrong. But the people who are saying he is crap im sure they have been watching a different player.

Spot on mate.

 

[stinger]

What are his wages now?

Read something about 70k I think.

 

[ijjysmith]

No, hes not.... we could go on for ages im sure.

Hes not a 15M player dont get me wrong. But the people who are saying he is crap im sure they have been watching a different player.

Absolutely hate that.

We've obviously been watching the same player. And have formed an opinion. I like a few others think James McCarthey isn't very good, and certainly not good enough for Everton.

 

[tim cahill]

Read something about 70k I think.

Wow. It's be hard for us to improve on that. Not sure if we could justify him being our highest earner.

 

[Shibbywiggles]

You forgot to mention that he's Belgian.

I'm sold.

Sign him up!!!

 

[FTY]

I rate James McCarthy, but not at 15m, and he's not the sort of centre mid we need, we need a box-to-box type, like Fer or Capoue, that's why we bid for 3 of those players, James McCarthy's just a mix between Osman and Gibson.

 

[Jags..class]

http://www.theshortfuse.com/arsenal.../1/8/3850800/james-mccarthy-arsenal-transfers a good article on the type of player James is