He has been atrocious at times but defensively in the first few weeks of Sam's tenure, he improved. Weirdly enough, I'd back him in a one-on-one with most players we go up against (not the top teams evidently). He isn't good enough. He's massively limited and at the moment not having a left-back capable of using his left foot or getting past the half-way line is killing us. I get that. I'm not disputing it - we need massively better but it is what it is and if we hadn't got him in, who would we have been playing there?