As of right now I'd probably put Animals, Wish you were here and Dark side of the moon as my top three
aye, the classic imperial-phase...the production is even today superlative.
Ummagumma, Obscured and Saucerful are the records I'm most excited to dive deeper into, as I've just heard them a couple of times before, and I remember enjoying it.
Ummagumma is their most under-rated studio album. It's split into 4 sections, with each band member writing their own section...
spoiler alert lol
Rick doing a spooky horror-movie soundtrack, sounds dated now but still packs a punch.
Roger has two tracks: the bonkers Pict number (bit cringey scots accent near the end, mind) and then a lovely acoustic folk song.
Dave has probably the strongest section: two trippy guitar-laden instrumentals then topped off with a moody classic rock song.
Nick's section is oft-derided, but i love it for the brooding mysterious dark ambience. Those 3 droney minutes in between that meandering flute & drums was a significant influence on the upcoming dark-ambient subgenre (along with some
Delia Derbyshire).
Obscured's songs are mostly a bit dull to my ears...but the final track, Absolutely Curtains, is absolutely magical!
Saucerful lacks direction, being as it coincided with Syd's last messy contributions. But Set The Controls is beautiful, one of their greatest tunes deffo.
I'm very fond of Syd's vocals, and the best tracks from Piper ranks up there with Floyd's best for me.
agreed...love Flaming and Bike from Syd, and also Astronomy Domine & Interstellar Overdrive (what a riff!).
There's two albums I've literally never listened to (other than one or two songs): The Final Cut and More.
More is a bit aimless in places, lots of incidental instrumental fluff. Nice, tho'. And has very strong songs too: Cirrus Minor, Nile, Cymbaline, Green is the Colour.
Final Cut is an emotional ride, more intellectual than The Wall, more political than Animals, very Roger-heavy. Lots of singing, less long instrumentals.
What about
Atom Heart Mother?
Endless river I find completely pointless.
yeah...it's nice enough but inoffensive, unchallenging.
It's also nice hearing music from their oldest records performed live by 'Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets' project, which I got on bluray like half a year ago.
Good call! Nick's a lad for doing that. I've got his Inside Out book but never got round to reading it...yet.
Wish they included this on Piper:
i recently got their "
Early Singles" release on CD, it's on there, as well as a couple of others i'd never heard before.
Also got Syd's solo albums...some very fine promise, tho' stark basic production. You can hear his influence on a lot of modern folky singer-songwriters.
Nick Mason has my favourite non-band work from them, eccentric stuff with Robert Wyatt on vocals.