Recently completed the Pink Floyd discography on CD, so I've been listening to different albums going back and forth from work recently. Today I went with Meddle, and it's such a good album. But... Fearless. Do anyone know if a version without the clown hymn exists? I just can't bear listening to it, and it's such a great song.
The greatest discography in musik. I recently recollected all their albums on vinyl after knowing them all by heart these last 25-ish years on CD. Like discovering them all over again! Best band ever, no question.
But i share your pain...Fearless is otherwise such a nice song too. They're not even reds, they're football-affiliation is either not-arsed or of the London clubs. I guess that chant made such a massive cultural impact that only Evertonians (and latterly maybe Man U fans) were turned off by it. Every other football fan i know think it's a pretty magical powerful chant, hence Floyd choosing to use it.
I did ages ago do an edit of Fearless, with a tasteful cut and fade-out, to remove the chant. I'm not even rabidly anti-RS as some on here, but i still don't wanna willingly hear that. it's on some old hard drive, i'll see if i can find it, and upload it.
Out of interest, you developing an albums ranking? Always find it interesting to see other Floydians' rankings. I'd go:
group one, the absolute best, no equal:
1. the wall
2. wish you were here
3. dark side of the moon
4. atom heart mother (epic title track is my favourite single piece of musik ever)
group two, as good as other favourite bands of mine...struggle to rank these, love them all equally:
5. the final cut
6. ummagumma
7. animals
8. piper at the gates of dawn
9. relics
group 3, some very good stuff, some filler:
10. meddle
11. more
12. obscured by clouds
13. a saucerful of secrets
group 4, missing Roger sounds only superficially like Floyd (just as his own solo work is also lacking that special something):
14. the division bell
15. endless river
16. a momentary lapse of reason