- Status
Rooney_Tunes
Player Valuation: £50m
Rooney_Tunes
Player Valuation: £50m
It's the manner of the defeats Eggs...
The lack of Fight, the lack of fitness.
This team is basically here for the paycheck; bar a few of them, the majority DON'T CARE...
Rogue Trader
Player Valuation: £500k
Carlito
Player Valuation: £40m
There's no direction from above.
Five years into the big takeover, and Kenwright is still the chairman, the new CEO has no relevant experience, the director of football has been retained after failing to assemble anything close to a balanced squad, and the academy continues to be littered with crony appointments.
There are no consequences for failure, despite the enormous amount of money that's been wasted since 2016. The only time someone cops for it is when fan unrest boils over to the point where it's causing the club embarrassment on television.
Luckily, Moshiri has continued to throw enough cash at the project to keep it stumbling along, but it would all turn very Randy Lerner very quickly if this changed.
Five years into the big takeover, and Kenwright is still the chairman, the new CEO has no relevant experience, the director of football has been retained after failing to assemble anything close to a balanced squad, and the academy continues to be littered with crony appointments.
There are no consequences for failure, despite the enormous amount of money that's been wasted since 2016. The only time someone cops for it is when fan unrest boils over to the point where it's causing the club embarrassment on television.
Luckily, Moshiri has continued to throw enough cash at the project to keep it stumbling along, but it would all turn very Randy Lerner very quickly if this changed.
TheBigIguana
Player Valuation: £100m
It starts with Moshiri who has no idea what he's doing and has yet to make the right appointment to any position. He's also failed to clearly define the structure of the footballing side of the club. Is Brands actually at the top? Some of our dealings and appointments say no. No amount of money fixes this dysfunction so it won't be getting fixed.
Still better than Bernard, Delph and Iwobi.
It could be an issue with club culture. That sort of thing is pervasive and you can't overturn it. But I don't think culture is the major issue. I know many will knock the "family" and "charity" aspects of the club, and these are real qualities of the culture of the football club that can't be ignored, but they don't necessarily indicate the club is soft. Certainly Kenwright has seemed this way in the past and nobody liked Elstone, but if you look at Moshiri, DBB, Brands, Ancelotti, these four don't give off the soft image. Moshiri has spent on the club and is bringing in a waterfront stadium (not to mention he bought the Liver Building for club headquarters... that's not a soft move), DBB stays in the shadows but her words on the Super Duper League shows she knows when to bring it, and it's simple enough to say that neither Brands nor Ancelotti give an air of soft or second rate about them.
So if it's not club culture, we have to jump straight to the players, with a mention to Walsh. Walsh did severe damage to the club. Martinez made decent signings on the whole and Silva's downfall was similarly tactical/predictable, but neither Allardyce nor Koeman picked good players to bring in and the Walsh-Koeman catfight was horrendous. That was a mistake by Moshiri in selecting the right people for the job (unless those were Kenwright mistakes). But since then Moshiri has shown enough Paul Anka about him to answer my questions. So unless you believe Moshiri is the bumbling fool who hires bad people (which Brands and Ancelotti seem to discredit), and if you've agreed that Walsh made huge mistakes that set the club back as much as 5-8 years, then it's the players.
There aren't enough players who've got enough bottle to get the job done. On the whole this squad is built with players who've got no bottle (Sigurdsson, Delph, Gomes), or depend upon confidence (Richarlison, Keane), or simply lack the skill or have aged past it (Coleman, Iwobi, Bernard, apparently Holgate). Add to that the injury and mistake prone (Mina, maybe Holgate fits here as well) and you're left with mercurial players (James and to a lesser extent Davies) and new players (Allan, Doucoure, James too), and you only have a few players with any will to take the game into their own hands. At the moment that may only be Digne (who has been absent at times), Doucoure (who is new and sometimes injured and let's see if his energy translates into dominance), Godfrey (who is new and out of position), and Pickford (who moves from blinder to blunder in the blink of a vowel.)
Did I miss anyone? Outside of a few players I have grown to hate (I won't mention again) and a few who don't have the requisite skills to perform for Everton (I'm looking at you Iwobi and Bernard), you have a band of misfits fit for an Aardman movie but not for anything above Premier League mid-table.
Granted, many of these players can stay and fit into a good squad, but we need 3 quality additions, specifically players with the physical and mental/emotional tools requisite to carry the team on their backs, to go along with those few players in the squad now who have any measure of the requisite character before we will see anything representing good football out of these.
Chrismac
Player Valuation: £15m
Last night we couldnt break down the team bottom of the pile and near relegated at christmas, Carlo turns to the bench and brings on the snail, little jimmy krankie and a guy out of a l'oreal advert.
Not one striker available, and tbh even if King was fit he wouldnt have got more than 7/8mins.
Having 2 sub goalkeepers repeatedly throughout the season embarrasses our club, so the only reason could be Carlo proving a point.
We havent had any worse a season injury wise than most of the other teams and yet we constantly hear "if we wouldve have our new signings fit all season" excuse threw out week after week.
They were all there last night and there was zero cohesion or plan throughout the 90mins.
Transfer strategy has to be hungry players wanting to win, not rejected/failure players stepping down and thinking they are better than us while taking massive salaries.
Not one striker available, and tbh even if King was fit he wouldnt have got more than 7/8mins.
Having 2 sub goalkeepers repeatedly throughout the season embarrasses our club, so the only reason could be Carlo proving a point.
We havent had any worse a season injury wise than most of the other teams and yet we constantly hear "if we wouldve have our new signings fit all season" excuse threw out week after week.
They were all there last night and there was zero cohesion or plan throughout the 90mins.
Transfer strategy has to be hungry players wanting to win, not rejected/failure players stepping down and thinking they are better than us while taking massive salaries.
Seathestars
Player Valuation: £60m
Koeman taking an age to agree to manage us, accepted
Koeman and his disrespect of the club, accepted
Koeman telling our best player, Lakaku, to go elsewhere if he wants to win, accepted
The new owner set the tone for me, in the most recent times anyway. He even talked about an expected loss.
I‘m not having a go at him and I’m glad he’s here, I’m just hoping he learns by his mistakes and learns not to accept 2nd best.
The rot needs to stop and I’m glad this poor form has happened so close to the end of the season.
Koeman and his disrespect of the club, accepted
Koeman telling our best player, Lakaku, to go elsewhere if he wants to win, accepted
The new owner set the tone for me, in the most recent times anyway. He even talked about an expected loss.
I‘m not having a go at him and I’m glad he’s here, I’m just hoping he learns by his mistakes and learns not to accept 2nd best.
The rot needs to stop and I’m glad this poor form has happened so close to the end of the season.
The binman chronicles
Player Valuation: £80m
The root has popped out somewhere in China. Going to take a long time getting to it.
Timbucktoo
Player Valuation: £15m
The root of our problems now go all the way back to the start of the premier league, money came flooding into football, but we somehow ended up always short of cash. When Kenwright came in to rescue us from the Johnson era, he was happy to settle for Walter Smith keeping us in the premier league, until the fans showed their frustration at getting turned over in Middlesboro in the cup.
The first few years under Moyes were up and down but when he got us up in the top six he wasn't backed financially to bring in the players that could of had us in the top four. Kenwright couldn't tell enough people that we couldn't compete with the rich clubs and that we needed a billionaire to come in to make up able to do so.
We got a billionaire, and made some very bad transfer decisions and we are left now in a very bad situation. Leicester have overtaken us, Leeds are back in the premier league and have high ambitions, West Ham took advantage of the usual top teams being out of form early in the season and look good to be in Europe next year. It will be very important to start next season well or we'll be fighting against relegation, and this group of players have shown they have no stomach to fight for 3 points when it is really needed.
The first few years under Moyes were up and down but when he got us up in the top six he wasn't backed financially to bring in the players that could of had us in the top four. Kenwright couldn't tell enough people that we couldn't compete with the rich clubs and that we needed a billionaire to come in to make up able to do so.
We got a billionaire, and made some very bad transfer decisions and we are left now in a very bad situation. Leicester have overtaken us, Leeds are back in the premier league and have high ambitions, West Ham took advantage of the usual top teams being out of form early in the season and look good to be in Europe next year. It will be very important to start next season well or we'll be fighting against relegation, and this group of players have shown they have no stomach to fight for 3 points when it is really needed.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
