Who was better than who

[Guru888]

guru u cocaine addled freak we miss us so much please return like mr jesus but before sunday i promise i will protect u from @Kurt.

Guru is back. It’s nice to see my name is still being spoken about so often in my forum, my followers have gone a week without hearing from a banned Guru but I am back, back to reclaim what’s mine. GOT. Happy Saturday Guru’ers

 

[COYBL25]

i ain't no threat to man nor snideyman

Just sheep.

 

[the sniderman]

Guru is back. It’s nice to see my name is still being spoken about so often in my forum, my followers have gone a week without hearing from a banned Guru but I am back, back to reclaim what’s mine. GOT. Happy Saturday Guru’ers

yes buddy!! we missed u take that crown and show them I shall not alert @Moomin or @Kurt. of ur return champ. into them.

 

[Kurt.]

Just sheep.

We shag them .... you eat them .... lol

 

[applecrumble]

All class and added things in different ways - I can't decide on a single one of them

 

[McBain]

Reading the thread v skipping to the last page

 

[Carloblues]

The speed Vs Cahill one give me a chuckle

18 months and then legged it or 7+ years of great service to arguably one of our most iconic player in the last 20 years

 

[AsiaAsia82]

The speed Vs Cahill one give me a chuckle

18 months and then legged it or 7+ years of great service to arguably one of our most iconic player in the last 20 years

Does that make Tony Hibbert better than Gary Stevens then?

 

[BNJ1878]

The speed Vs Cahill one give me a chuckle

18 months and then legged it or 7+ years of great service to arguably one of our most iconic player in the last 20 years

I'm chuckling at how many rate Cahill as some kind of Everton legend.

Commited, without doubt. But an average player on technical ability. (Which is what I read this thread is about, maybe I'm wrong? @Guru888?)

 

[Terrarian]

The speed Vs Cahill one give me a chuckle

18 months and then legged it or 7+ years of great service to arguably one of our most iconic player in the last 20 years

Speed was a better player, that is the question, Cahill was great at certain things but very limited. Speed was a baller.

 

[Guru888]

Speed was a better player, that is the question, Cahill was great at certain things but very limited. Speed was a baller.

The question was solely on who was the better player, for example Lukaku was better than Naismith, but I’d rather go for a pint with Naismith

 

[Exeter_Gently]

Pienaar is my favourite Everton player since 2000 so it must include him but Trev Gareth and Tim . I would say that an Arteta type is what would be nice this summer please Mr moshiri.

On his day he was worth the entrance fee alone,sumptuous footballer.

I feel he'd be looked upon even more fondly if he'd have gotten his hands on a medal... Could say the same about alot of players to be honest but he was superb.


Also Joe Parkinson was one of the best midfielders I've seen at the club but unfortunately played on through bad medical advice which finished him.

Wouldn't pick anyone above him,but that's just my extremely humble opinion.

 

[BNJ1878]

Also Joe Parkinson was one of the best midfielders I've seen at the club but unfortunately played on through bad medical advice which finished him.

Agreed.

An excellent player. Lord knows what he'd cost today.

 

[larbert toffee]

This is more of a test

Fellaini
Digne
Mirallas
Jagielka
Heath

Mirallas was never at the races, too inconsistent, stuck up his own arse and saw us off for mugs, however the other four on your list were decent players and did a turn for us, Inchy would have achieved so much more for us if it wasn't for his bad injury.

 

[larbert toffee]

1) I didn't see Steven, my dad says Trevor Steven
2) Arteta
3) Parkinson (massively underrated)
4) Speed was a better player, but Cahill did more for the club. Speed was like a Cahill who was better on the ball and had better technique.

As the father of two Evertonian lads I salute the fact you consulted your old man when unsure